Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Sandy Springs GA

Cute little shop! Plus the pies can be made gluten-free—which is so great for when my sister is in town! I recommend calling ahead as they typically only bake a few at a time. My personal go-tos depending on my mood... Their apple pie's generous crumble topping over the cinnamon-y and tart apples is to die for. I usually bring these out for the holidays to appease the in-laws. (Pro-tip: Ask about the Cloud 9.) And of course - I'm a chocoholic so the Chocolate Cream Pie is a dream. Chocolate mousse, buttercream, and oreo crust... yeah. Edit: Um the new chocolate chip cookie pop? It is freaking amazing. Underrated

Love the coconut cream pie

Outrageously delicious pie! It's hard to get true artisan delicious pie anywhere. The grocery store is fine but this is TOP TIER! The mini ones are so awesome and the flavors are awesome. Highly recommend!

My wife just got me a couple pies from here for my birthday and my mind cannot process how exceptional it was! I can’t wait to try more options.

Outstanding

Tried the coconut cream pie, key lime pie, and the Cookie… they completely lacked any flavor. The filling of the coconut and key lime were extremely thick, they’re very dense pies and lacked flavor… worst pies I’ve ever had. Other locations out of ATL are good, this store just is not. Very disappointed with how off the pies were. We ended up throwing them out after a couple bites. They just don’t taste good at all.

Worse Buttermilk Sky Pie ever!!! I normally go to the original store in Knoxville but was in atlanta and went to this store. DONT GO! I got a coconut pie and cherry and both were horrible. The crust was nothing lurk the original which was shortbread. My sister who loves the pie at the original store in Knoxville said it taste like a whole blend of sugar. Run from this franchise