Avellino's Wood Fire Pizzeria Brookhaven

Best Pizza in America

Superb food and service from, in my opinion, Brookhaven’s premier pizza place. Cannot recommend enough.

Definitely was better under their old owner. Their take on the fromaggi used to be amazing and is now not good. However their new Sicilian crust is very good though

Quality of the pizza has slipped a little, maybe they will dial back in

Please bring back the fried ravioli

Updating my review after my most recent visit - Shrinkflation has hit this place with a bang! They raised entree prices, lowered the portions by a LOT, and took away the free salad that came with every entree. This has become fine dining prices without any additional staff or service. They are super nice but when the same 2 employees are hostesses, servers, and busboys they can’t keep up with what a $100 2 person meal requires. Portions were shockingly smaller, I mean my penne vodka had maybe 15-20 noodles in it. Lots of sauce, I was left wondering if they ran out of pasta. Cheesy Garlic bread is smaller and was mostly bread. Nobody checked on us for drink refills or dessert. I’m disappointed - I used to love this place. ——— Food is always great, service is friendly but the staff and kitchen is absolute chaos on weekends. Some order would be nice as it gets so busy that people tend to seat themselves, orders get missed etc. However staff is really friendly and has that local neighborhood feel so I’ll continue going back!

The food was average, very noisy.

This was out go to pizzeria but the portions have gone done to the point that there are better choices. Ordered a pizza with pepperoni and a third of the pizza was crust and missing part of the pie. The cheese bread was a good appetizer but it has shrunk to half its size.