The Rusty Tapp Colorado BBQ & Catering

The food was good. The side dishes expensive. They had me with the okra best I have had in a resteraunt in years. I will go back just for the okra!!

First timers, have driven by numerous times and ever know it was there. I had prime rib dip which was awesome, wife and my cousins had 2 meat plates and all raved about their selections, cousins had been there before a couple of times, glad they recommended it

Love this place! Pulled pork is so tender!!! Parking: Lots

Ribs were pretty terrible- Dry as jerky, with caked on 'rub' that was essentially 90% burnt paprika, & tasted like chalk. I could smoke a better rack of ribs with my eyes closed to be honest. Everything else was okay, turkey was decent, smoked prime rib was *decent* but not amazing, & the pulled pork was decent as well- I've had much worse, but much better as well. Of the 3 I'd say the smoked prime rib was the best, but still far from 'legit bbq'. the baked potato was tasty, although these were underdone as well. Overall, very 'meh' experience if I'm being brutally honest. Update: 12/2023 Yeah, officially won't be back, ever. 100% over hyped considering the general reviews ...dry across the board and a comedic attempt at BBQ overall. Unwelcoming staff. BBQ sauce isn't BBQ sauce....and yes I know ketchup is base...but it's not used 99.9:.1...LOL..you're serving ketchup with a splash of color. Mac n cheese lukewarm, gritty, unmelted. House made ranch: watered down ranch..fried pickles were just stale fried salt chips, chewy as everything else.. Texas toast was about the worst Texas toast I think I've come across in my entire life. You can't be serious. You guys know damn well what im talking about as well. Place is a joke. Cheers

Their brisket is awesome! My boyfriend usually complains about restaurants Brisket but not here, he was also impressed.

First, it's overpriced, even for the Highlands Ranch metro area where people are all presumed to be rich. They charge for extra bbq sauce........gimme a break. A $25 plate only comes with one side, and certain meats are $3 extra. Order a plate of pulled pork, ribs, and brisket, and it will come to $31 with only one side. The ribs were good, but something about the texture makes me think there was either braising or boiling involved prior to smoking. The pulled pork was dry and boring. The turkey was tasty but it was cut way too thin, like lunch meat. Beans were good, but their Texas Toast is a joke.

I got the Wednesday special. Pulled pork sandwich with fries Really great service today! I definitely would recommend this place for BBQ