St. James Gate

This is one of my favorite restaurants on the Upper West Side. Many great menu items, but my favorite is their chicken pot pie (see pic). I also often order the bruschetta - it’s always prepared perfectly. The ambiance of an Irish pub is full of character. The food, the drinks, and the service here is consistently excellent.

I don’t usually post or take time and energy to add ‘reviews’ here. However, tonight I had the Worst apple pie I ever had or seen! How the apples were able to look dryAND boiled, is miraculous and disturbing. The crust was rubbery like it had been freezer burnt then microwaved!!! Horrible! Also, the bartender didn’t seem friendly unless you looked like you were going to drink/spend enough that might promise I big tip. I’m from Miami. This apple pie was the absolute worst. Had to leave a review.

Literally soooo good! DEFINITELY order the mozzarella wedges. 1000/10. Fish and chips were solid and the burger was great. Dan took care of us and he was the best! We love this place and will absolutely be back

LOVE THIS PLACE. The atmosphere is perfect and very comfortable. I feel right at home. Go here.

Sehr lecker, nette Bedienung!

Nice wee Irish owned pub with friendly Irish staff. Cheers from Belfast!