I accidentally tapped the 5 stars. I’ve never eaten one of their cheesecakes. Checking out reviews first.
Local legend that still holds up. My family has been coming here for years. Dense. Not too sweet. Creamy. Plain crust so the cheese filling is what takes precedence in the palette. Cash only $$
The coffee here was very good but the cheesecake was alright. For a place that pride's itself for it's cheesecake they can do better. The crust was lackluster and the cake itself is not as rich as it can be. It's a 6.5 out of 10 compared to be the best that NYC has to offer. If I was in the neighborhood I would swing by maybe but I am not going out of my way to grab a slice. I do like the owner, the people here and the calm friendly environment. Hence the 4 out of 5 stars.
More bad reviews than good reviews, so no I won't be visiting any time soon
Saw this featured on NY Live as the best cheesecake in NY. Couldn't wait to try. It was actually the WORST I've ever had. Tasteless and dry...we tossed in right in the garbage. I don't understand the 2 extremes when reading the reviews.