Plum Tomatoes by La Sorrentina

I am a local and try over and over to be gracious and allow them the benefit of the doubt but not matter what every time I order from them something is wrong. Wrong topping. Cold pizza. Forgotten soda. No pen to sign credit card receipt on delivery! The list continues. At this point I’ll drive to Howard beach to get a pizza or risk the spot at 116th before coming back here. Even after speaking to someone claiming to be a manager and that notes would be put on my account I am still left feeling like the annoying customer when really I just want a decent value for my $45 pizza order. Good luck if you decide to go here.

Worst Sicilian slices ever. Dried up sauce horrible not melted cheese,better off a frozen pie.

The best Margherita pizza ever

We had a birthday party here last night. The feedback from our guests was identical- fantastic food and service. We were in the private room and had a DJ. We fit about 40 guests comfortably. The party menu had choices for everyone. We had a wonderful time and highly recommend this wonderful local restaurant!

Best buffalo slice in the tri state area

Food and service were good. Staff was nice.