Mary's Pizza Shack

We eat here alot and feel like the food has gone downhill - meatballs soggy with some pieces that were like little rubber band consistency- didn’t seem like they were meat - been going to Mary’s for years and never had a problem Like this -did mention to waitress and she offered to get me something else

Great pizza!

We love Mary’s Pizza Shack. The pizza is always a 5 out of 5 stars and the service is quick and done with a smile. This review is based on 3 different experiences, all of which ended with- oddly enough- missing Caesar salad dressing. Episode 1: “Shame on you.” My wife placed a carry out order over the phone for a large pepperoni and Caesar salad as part of a type of “meal deal.” I picked up the food, opened up everything at home. No Caesar salad dressing. Weird. Episode 2: “Shame on me.” Wife placed the same type of order as before, pizza and a salad. I picked it up and when opened at home… no Caesar salad dressing. Guess I should’ve checked the bag before leaving. Episode 3: “How…?” Mom came into town, ordered online for delivery… two large pizzas, breadsticks, Caesar salad. Everything was there, including ranch and pizza sauce for the breadsticks, except for the Caesar salad dressing. I like to think of myself as a reasonable person (who doesn’t?!), but how does the dressing get missed time and time again? I’m disappointed, bothered, and a bit baffled as to how this has happened three times in the span of a couple of months.

Food is normally pretty good but last time we went our waiter barely came to our table. We were sharing 2 pairs of silverware for 5 people for 15 minutes before she noticed, and we couldn't flag her down either, wouldn't even look at us

Very busy. The he and she meatballs are always good.

The pizza was really good.