Edgewater Inn Pizza

This place should not be called the Edgewater Inn - it looks and tastes nothing like the iconic pizza I and so many others have loved for over 50 years. The crust was soggy, the sauce lacks the sweetness of the original, the toppings tasted off and the cheese was non existent. We were there during dinner time on the weekend and no one was eating - only a few at the bar. The walls and seating have been redone to give it an updated look, but all of the pictures and history of the place is gone. Heartbreaking. (I wrote a similar review in March of ‘23 and the owner Niya replied that she’d send me a gift card to try it again. She never sent one, even after an email saying she would.) We still gave the place a second chance today, but we’re done. Change the name. It’s not the Edgewater Inn anymore.

Delicious local pizza spot! Friendly staff & amazing pizza! Drinks are great too.

Pretty good pizza but deceptive business practices. They charge a 5% take-out fee and a 5% auto gratuity on all take out orders. These hidden fees are dishonest and unnecessary. Just raise your menu prices instead.

This is my new favorite spot. The prosciutto bruschetta is a must. And the sourdough pizza crust is what keeps me coming back. Everyone is super nice here and all these bad reviews are fake. Perfect neighborhood spot for a drink, some pizza and meeting nice people. 10/10

If you need Pizza, ......and you are close to Edgewater- this is the place.

Great place.I think new owner are super.

I experienced very slow service on a Friday night, unfortunately, even when the restaurant wasn’t close to being full. My friends and I waited over 40 minutes for our pizza to come out and then waited a long time for the check, while there were only about 6 people at the bar. I don’t recommend coming here if you have celiac disease; the only safe option is a salad and the portion is small.

We love this place!! The food is always delicious and the service is so friendly. Yesterday, they seemed to think their service was slow, but not to us! The staff went above and beyond to make us feel special. Prices are very affordable and we look forward to supporting this business for years to come! The pizza is awesome and the prosciutto bruschetta app is heavenly.