Croton Reservoir Tavern

had the spicy chicken sandwich, it was yummmmmmy :) also enjoyed happy hour sangria with friends!

I spent a Friday evening with a friend. It’s a nice bar, with good food, welcoming staff, and quick service. I can’t say there was something special worth mentioning, but it has everything for a nice drink/bar food experience.

Staff were courteous. Service was reasonable and food was ok.

Nice place

Wow. This bar is NYC in a bottle (excuse obvious pun). Great atmosphere, quiet, understated, roomy yet clubby at the same time. Awesome location, great wines, mind blowing whiskey and Bourbon list (try the Boyntons bourbon on the rocks). I like that the music is background rather than in your face and great 80s-to-now playlist (special props for Blue Oyster Cult pirate recording). I like that the food is limited in scope, but well executed, I like the bar staff, friendly, knowledgeable, efficient, engaging (thanks Kosovar Lee for the experience). Highly recommended if you like what I’ve described.

I came here for a speed dating event on Valentine's Day 2024, which was being held in the cellar. I was hungry. Before the event started, I inhaled a Croton Crunch spicy chicken sandwich. It was delicious and filling. My belly was happy. It cost under $30 with gratuity. Service was good and attentive, but the place was almost full so there was a lot of noise. I prefer quieter places, but for extroverts who like to yell, this place is for them.

I absolutely love this place my first time coming here my best friend Amanda, who served me is a really really great server not Only that she works really hard for what she does. I would definitely be coming back here along with my family there’s no way I will not be back here. This place is phenomenal and the drinks are perfect.

O atendimento é super educado, tem bebidas das mais variadas, incluindo chopps e cervejas diversas. É um típico bar americano com porções bem relevantes e a música ambiente também é ótima, com muito rock. Vale a visita para tomar uma cerveja no bar ou até para jantar mesmo.

Came in after late night ice skating at Bryant Park. Absolutely enjoyed their hot apple cider and Mango Habanero cocktail! Both hit the spot after our fun activities outside in the cold.

I don't know I just love the building I didn't Go outside