Checkle
Search
For Businesses
Caragiulo's Italian American
Menu
Caragiulo's Italian American Menu
$$
·
Italian
,
Restaurant
69 S Palm Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236
Order Online
Suggest Edit
Menus may not be up to date.
Suggest Edit
Know a great happy hour or special for this location?
Add Happy Hour
Nearby Locations
Chart House
4.3
(9,496 Reviews)
Dry Dock Waterfront Grill
4.7
(3,352 Reviews)
Rincon Tolteca Mexican restaurant corp
4.5
(345 Reviews)
IL Panificio Siesta
4.2
(132 Reviews)
Village Cafe
4.5
(1,706 Reviews)
Island House Tap and Grill
4.4
(1,657 Reviews)
Star Thai & Sushi Siesta Key
4.4
(536 Reviews)
The Beach Club
4.0
(1,516 Reviews)
Bean Coffeehouse
3.9
(427 Reviews)
Top Cuisines Near Me
Restaurants
Bar
Breakfast
American
Coffee shop
Pizza
Cafe
Italian
Bar & grill
Bakery
Sandwich shop
Seafood
Hamburger
Ice cream shop
Chicken wings
Popular Cities
New York
Chicago
Brooklyn
San Antonio
Houston
CURBSIDE PICK UP
TONIGHT'S FAMILY-STYLE DINNERS (2, 4 or 6 ppl)
APPETIZERS / SOUP / SALADS
DINNER ENTREES (M-S 4-8pm)
PIZZA
PACKAGE BEER TOGO
PACKAGE WINE TO GO
APPETIZERS
SOUPS / SALADS
DINNER PASTA
PIZZA
ENTREES
SIDES
DESSERT SPEC
CURBSIDE PICK UP
START HERE FOR CURBSIDE PICK UP
PRESS HERE to enter your Vehicle info as a check item, please. We'll come out with your order.
$0.00
TONIGHT'S FAMILY-STYLE DINNERS (2, 4 or 6 ppl)
LINGUINE JAMBALAYA ($35/$65/$95)
Shrimp, chicken, & sausage, onions peppers and mushrooms, tomato cream sauce over linguine. Served with Family-Style House Salad and Bread.
$35.00
GRILLED RIBEYE $32/$60/$87
Grilled Ribeye, portobello cream sauce with grilled asparagus. Served with Family-Style House Salad and Bread.
$32.00
APPETIZERS / SOUP / SALADS
MEATBALLS AL FORNO
ricotta + san Marzano tomato + mozzarella
$14.95
BRUSCHETTA CAPRESE
local tomatoes + red onion + house-made mozzarella + basil + baslamico
$11.95
FRIED CALAMARI
fried calamari only with Sicilian marinara & Sardinian aioli
$14.95
SM HOUSE SALAD
carrot + tomato + onion + calamata olive + house vinaigrette
$5.95
LG HOUSE SALAD
carrot + tomato + onion + calamata olive + house vinaigrette
$10.95
SM CHOPPED '1989'
grilled chicken + salami + chickpeas bean + tomato + pepperoncini + olives + parmigiana + creamy dressing
$7.95
LG CHOPPED SALAD
grilled chicken + salami + chickpeas bean + tomato + pepperoncini + olives + parmigiana + creamy dressing
$11.95
SMALL SICILIAN CAESAR SALAD
romaine + radicchio + fried caper crumbs + golden raisins + peppadew peppers + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing
$12.95
LARGE SICILIAN CAESAR SALAD
romaine + radicchio + fried caper crumbs + golden raisins + peppadew peppers + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing
$16.95
SMALL SICILIAN + CHICKEN
romaine + radicchio + fried caper crumbs + golden raisins + peppadew peppers + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing + organic chicken
$14.95
LARGE SICILIAN + CHICKEN
romaine + radicchio + fried caper crumbs + golden raisins + peppadew peppers + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing + organic chicken
$17.95
SMALL CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD
romaine + shaved parmigiana + fried caper crumbs + Caesar dressing
$10.50
LARGE CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD
romaine + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing
$14.50
WEDDING SOUP
spinach stracciatella + pastina + small meatballs
$4.95
DINNER ENTREES (M-S 4-8pm)
SPAGHETTI W/ MEATBALLS
our house-made meatballs
$18.95
SPAGHETTI + SAUSAGE
$18.95
SPAGHETTI + SAUSAGE + MEATBALL
$18.95
PASOLINI
rigatoni + roasted chicken + crumbled sausage + gorgonzola cream + oven-dried tomatoes
$22.50
PASTA MIA
pick your pasta: add your favorite sauce
$12.95
RAVIOLI BARESE
spinach + pomodori + olives + ricotta salata
$18.95
LASAGNA Al FORNO
bolognese + béchamel
$20.95
PASTA Alla ZASA
rigatoni + roasted rapini & cauliflower + sun-dried tomatoes + caper + harissa bread crumbs
$16.95
BEEF TORTELLONI A La VODKA
crispy pancetta + stracciatella mozzarella + vodka-tomato crema
$20.50
LINGUINE Fra DIAVOLO
shrimp + clams + mussels+ squid in a spicy tomato broth
$22.00
CHICKEN PARMIGIANA DINNER
pan fried organic chicken breast with marinara + mozzarella + spaghetti
$23.95
EGGPLANT PARMESAN Al FORNO
layered crispy eggplant + plum tomato + ricotta + mozzarella
$18.95
PICATTA STYLE VEAL
artichoke + caper + oyster mushroom + lemon-butter + arancini verde
$26.95
CHICKEN MARSALA
pan roasted organic chicken breast + roasted cippolini + wild mushroom gravy + roasted potatoes
$23.95
LINGUINE JAMBALAYA
Blackened Scottish Salmon with spinach, heirloom tomatoes & parmesan cream over linguine.
$14.00
RIBEYE
Pan seared breaded chicken with tomato, fresh mozzarella, onion & lemon-balsamic glaze over spring mix lettuce.
$14.50
3 - CANNOLI
crispy miniature pastries + sweet ricotta + chocolate chips
$6.95
LIMONCELLO CHEESECAKE
lemon cream + biscotto crust
$8.95
PIZZA
DAVINCI
fennel sausage + mushroom + pepperoni
$17.95
BIANCA ROSSA
white pizza with roasted garlic ricotta + arugula
$17.95
JOE Da GREEK
calamata olives + baby spinach + feta + tomatoes
$17.95
POLLO PAZZO
blackened chicken + sweet onion + 3 cheeses
$15.95
MARGHERITA
san marzano tomatoes + basil + house-made mozzarella
$17.95
PEAR & GORGONZOLA
caramelized onions + white balsamic-honey drizzle
$17.95
WILD MUSHROOM & FONTINA
with truffle garlic aioli
$17.95
CHEESE PIZZA
with sauce + mozzarella
$14.95
CALZONE
stuffed with ricotta + any 2 toppings
$17.95
PIZZA MIA
cheese pizza your way with 3 toppings
$17.95
EGGPLANT PARMESAN PIZZA
crispy eggplant + ricotta + basil pesto + fresh mozzarella
$17.95
PACKAGE BEER TOGO
CORONA BOTTLE
Individual Bottles or 6-packs
$3.00
BUDWEISER
Individual Bottles or 6-packs
$2.25
MILLER LIGHT
Individual Bottles or 6-packs
$2.50
STELLA ARTOIS
Individual Bottles or 6-packs
$3.25
MICHELOB LIGHT
Individual Bottles or 6-packs
$2.50
AMSTEL LIGHT
Individual Bottles or 6-packs
$3.00
PACKAGE WINE TO GO
PROSECCO 750ml (Bin 1)
Pizzolato Fields, Veneto, DOC, Brut
$21.00
PINOT GRIGIO 750ml (Bin 2)
La Fiera, Veneto, IGT, Italy
$21.00
CHARDONNAY 750ml (Bin 3)
William Hill, Central Coast, California
$21.00
SAUVIGNON BLANC (Bin 4)
Cultivar, Napa Valley, California
$21.00
MERLOT 750ml (Bin 23)
Albertoni, California, 2015
$21.00
CABERNET SAUVIGNON (Bin 25)
Albertoni, California, 2016
$21.00
CHIANTI 750ml (Bin 21)
Fattoria Campigiana, Italy 2017
$24.00
PINOT NOIR 750ml (Bin 27)
Lola, Central Coast, Sonoma, 2017
$28.00
APPETIZERS
ROMAN ARTICHOKES
crispy fried hearts + goat cheese fonduta + truffle-aioli
$11.95
CALAMARI FRITTO MISTO
calamari + gardiniera + condimenti
$15.95
MEATBALLS AL FORNO
ricotta + san Marzano tomato + mozzarella
$14.95
MUSSELS 'NDUJA
fennel sausage crumbles + scallions + n'duja broth + crostini
$16.95
AVOCADO BRUSCHETTA
heirloom tomatoes + burrata + herb salad + radish
$14.95
CHICKEN LIVER PATE
shallot marmellata + balsamic + Tuscan toast
$10.95
CAPRESE BOARD
House-made mozzarella + local tomato + basil + red onion + balsamico
$15.50
VEGETARIANO BOARD
seasonal grilled vegetable + goat cheese + aged balsamic
$14.95
SALUMI E FORMAGGI BOARD
prosciutto di parma + soppresata + pistachio mortadella + giardiniera + parmigiana + gorgonzola dolce + fresh mozzarella + local honeycomb
$19.95
FRIED CALAMARI
fried calamari only with Sicilian marinara & Sardinian aioli
$14.95
SOUPS / SALADS
SMALL HOUSE SALAD
carrot + tomato + onion + calamata olive + cucumber + house vinaigrette
$10.50
SMALL CHOPPED 1989 SALAD
grilled organic chicken + salami + chickpeas bean + tomato + pepperoncini + olives + parmigiana + creamy dressing
$13.50
SMALL ROASTED BEET & AVOCADO SALAD
goat cheese fondue + orange + shallot vinaigrette + local lettuces + caramelized walnuts
$13.95
SMALL SICILIAN CAESAR SALAD
romaine + radicchio + fried caper crumbs + golden raisins + peppadew peppers + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing
$12.95
SMALL CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD
romaine + shaved parmigiana + fried caper crumbs + Caesar dressing
$10.50
SMALL TUSCAN KALE SALAD
burrata + toasted breadcrumbs + Spanish almonds + dried cherries + lemon-vinaigrette
$11.50
LARGE HOUSE SALAD
carrot + tomato + onion + calamata olive + house vinaigrette
$14.50
LARGE CHOPPED 1989 SALAD
grilled organic chicken + salami + chickpeas bean + tomato + pepperoncini + olives + parmigiana + creamy dressing
$17.95
LARGE ROASTED BEET & AVOCADO SALAD
goat cheese fondue + orange + shallot vinaigrette + local lettuces + caramelized walnuts
$17.95
LARGE SICILIAN CAESAR SALAD
romaine + radicchio + fried caper crumbs + golden raisins + peppadew peppers + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing
$16.95
LARGE CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD
romaine + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing
$14.50
LARGE TUSCAN KALE SALAD
baby carrots + whipped ricotta + toasted breadcrumbs + lemon-vinaigrette
$14.50
WEDDING SOUP
spinach stracciatella + pastina + small meatballs
$7.95
ZUPPA Di IERI
yesterday's soup, better today
$7.95
SALAD SPECIAL
$29.00
DINNER PASTA
SPAGHETTI W/ MEATBALLS
our house-made meatballs
$18.95
SPAGHETTI + SAUSAGE
$18.95
SPAGHETTI + SAUSAGE + MEATBALL
$18.95
PASTA MIA
pick your pasta: add your favorite sauce
$12.95
RAVIOLI BARESE
spinach + pomodori + olives + ricotta salata
$18.95
LASAGNA Al FORNO
bolognese + béchamel
$20.95
ANGEL HAIR ARRABIATA
shrimp + mussels + clams + white fish + calamari + stewed san marzano + arancia
$29.50
BEEF TORTELLONI A La VODKA
crispy pancetta + stracciatella mozzarella + vodka-tomato crema
$20.50
SPAGHETTI & CEDAR KEY CLAMS
white wine-garlic broth + botarga crumb + parsley + fresno chili
$23.95
PASOLINI
rigatoni + roasted chicken + crumbled sausage + gorgonzola cream + oven-dried tomatoes
$22.50
RIGATONI ROMANA
braised oxtail & portobello ragu + burrata
$22.50
PASTA SPEC
Call in for today's special 941-951-0866
$30.00
PIZZA
DAVINCI
fennel sausage + mushroom + pepperoni
$17.95
BIANCA ROSSA
white pizza with roasted garlic ricotta + arugula
$17.95
EGGPLANT PARMESAN PIZZA
crispy eggplant + ricotta + basil pesto + fresh mozzarella
$17.95
FIVE LILY
sweet & red onions + crispy bacon + garlic + charred scallion + chive + smoked mozzarella
$17.95
MARGHERITA
san marzano tomatoes + basil + house-made mozzarella
$17.95
AGRO DOLCE
grilled pineapple + capicola + jalapeno + mozzarella
$17.95
PEAR & GORGONZOLA
caramelized onions + white balsamic-honey drizzle
$17.95
WILD MUSHROOM & FONTINA
with truffle garlic aioli
$17.95
CHEESE PIZZA
with sauce + mozzarella
$14.95
CALZONE
stuffed with ricotta + any 2 toppings
$17.95
PIZZA MIA
cheese pizza your way with 3 toppings
$17.95
JOE Da GREEK
calamata olives + baby spinach + feta + tomatoes
$17.95
ENTREES
CHICKEN PARMIGIANA DINNER
pan fried organic chicken breast with marinara + mozzarella + spaghetti
$23.95
CHICKEN MARSALA
pan roasted organic chicken breast + roasted cippolini + wild mushroom gravy + roasted potatoes
$23.95
SEARED LOCAL GROUPER
roasted tomato confit + artichoke + spinach + caper butter + risotto cake
$36.95
FILETTO Di MANZO
black angus beef tenderloin + bone marrow butter + port glaze + crispy brussels sprouts + truffle risotto
$37.95
EGGPLANT PARMESAN Al FORNO
layered crispy eggplant + plum tomato + ricotta + mozzarella
$18.95
CHICKEN PICATTA
artichoke + oyster mushroom + caper + lemon-butter + green pea risotto
$24.95
PORK TENDERLOIN MARSALA
cipollini + wild mushroom gravy crispy leeks + gorgonzola polenta
$24.95
PORK SPEC
Call in for today's special preparation: 941-951-0866
$33.00
SIDES
ROASTED CAULIFLOWER
with calabrian aioli + spicy crumbs
$9.95
CRISPY BRUSSELS SPROUTS
with spicey honey
$9.95
CACCIO E PEPE FRIES
with cracked pepper + parmigiano + aioli
$8.95
CHARRED BROCCOLINI
with lemon + EVOO
$9.95
TRUFFLE RISOTTO
$9.95
CACIO E PEPE RISOTTO
with parmesan + cracked pepper & chives
$9.95
ADDITIONAL SIDE OF FOCACCIA BREAD
all salads, pastas & entrees come with a side of focaccia bread, add if you would like to order additional extra bread
$3.50
SIDE 2 MEATBALLS
$6.50
SIDE 2 SAUSAGE LINKS
$7.50
SIDE ANCHOVIES
$4.00
SIDE MIXED VEGETABLES
$9.95
SIDE PASTA
$6.95
SIDE SAUTEED SPINACH
$9.95
DESSERT SPEC
3 - CANNOLI
crispy miniature pastries + sweet ricotta + chocolate chips
$6.95
6 - CANNOLI
$10.95
ZEPPOLI & GELATO
crispy zeppoli fritters + espresso gelato + crema inglese
$9.95
SPUMONI SUNDAE
pistachio + vanilla + amarena cherry gelato + dark rum chocolate brownie + cream
$9.95
CHIARA'S TIRAMISU
lady fingers + espresso + frangelico + mascarpone + cocoa
$9.95
Menu Gallery
Menu Gallery