Brooklyn Bagels & Deli Beneva - Now Buddy's Bagels!

4.3
(512 Reviews)
Permanently closed
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo

Ratings of Brooklyn Bagels & Deli Beneva - Now Buddy's Bagels!

google
Google
4.4
(471 Reviews)
tripadvisor
TripAdvisor
3.5
(41 Reviews)

Happy Hours & Specials

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?


Photos

  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo

Location & Hours

6970 S Beneva Rd
Sarasota, FL 34238

Recent Reviews

google
Nov 2023
Best bagels in Sarasota. Now open everyday.
google
Oct 2023
Got a lox bagel. It was $12.99 and worth every penny. I was just visiting the area but next time I return, I will be back. Wish I had taken a pic!
google
Oct 2023
Definitely NOT Brooklyn bagels but not the worst bagels either.
google
Oct 2023
I stopped going here because not only does the service suck, they solicit tips up front before rendering any type of service. Who the hell tips a counter service worker anyway? It's like tipping at McDonalds or Burger King...it doesn't happen nor should it. Brooklyn's is one of these annoying places that gives you that bullcrap computer screen with the tip option front and center. The food is OK but I won't go back due to the tip mooching on top of already sky high prices. The last time I wrote a review about this the jerk owner wrote that this type of tipping option is "standard in most industries." That pissed me off even more and I won't give that dude another penny. Too bad because I have a big family and live down the street.I have an even bigger review count on Google Reviews too.Too bad
google
Oct 2023
The owners changed and so did the menu, quality and ingredients. They removed platters, cut back on variety of bagels. My everything bagel is not what it used to be. Bagel was either missing or very light on the ingredients for an everything bagel. They used to run out of them by 10am. It was 12 so I was surprised they still had some. Now I know why. My last three breakfast sandwiches all had very hard bacon. Not sure if they changed brands or are cooking them differently, but they also have less cheese. It should have been a sign when the team was no longer there. Some had stayed from original owner to last owner. All new faces now. Sad to see a great business change, and not for better.
google
Sep 2023
New owners are a joke! Not the same! Place been closed for no reason in middle of week twice now? Never happened with old owners
google
Sep 2023
Just bought some everything bagels No seasoning on them Completely disappointed Also smaller then ever ! Lox & egg Jersey girl Far better !! I have a photo of you want to see !!
google
Sep 2023
Use to be the best spot in town for a bagel. They are now under new management and might just be the worst spot in town to get a bagel. Quality went down the toilet. Bagels are not good the new owners use cheap nasty bacon on the sandwiches. Really really dissapointed and miss the old owners :(
google
Sep 2023
Not Brooklyn Bagels anymore, different bagels,it's Lox and Egg now, decent bagels,more expensive
google
Sep 2023
They haven’t been the same since the original owners were bought out. Bagels are completely different and the service is horrible. I waited over 30 minutes today, only for them to give me a wrong order. Mistakes happen and I get that. In this case it comes across very intentional because they knew they were out of a certain type of bagel but instead of checking with me on an alternative, they tried to sub it out with one that looked like it without saying anything. By the time I went to correct them, they didn’t have the type of bagel left in stock. This is a place my family and I get bagels at every week but after the decrease in quality of food and service I don’t plan on ever going back.


Nearby Locations

Loading...

(941) 993-1577

6970 S Beneva Rd, Sarasota, FL 34238