Milton Your Pie needs a comprehensive cleaning. All the tables were sticky and dirty. Customers were cleaning their own table tops. I’d start with sanding every table top and revarnishing.
Terrible service. Placed a to go order, came 30 min later and the ticket hadn’t even been taken off the computer.
Was supposed to be closed at 9 PM, but locked their doors 20 minutes early. If you’re going to close your doors early, then update your hours online please.
This is a solid place for a quick meal. The buffalo chicken pizza was pretty good, but didn’t have enough buffalo sauce. The create your own pizza was tasty. The cherry gelato was terrific. Prices make for a good value. Staff was all HS teens but service was great.
Vegetarian options: I had my best experience today @ your pie! Travis made the best vegan pizza I ever had @ your pie! #keep #winning Travis!