Uncle Vinny's NY Pizzeria

One of my favorite pizza places in town the owner is amazing and one of the kindest people you will ever meet and they have the best ghost pepper ranch ever I like how you can build your own slice too that way you can have every slice different if you want this place is a must go!!!

Great pizza. Service is top notch. Ordered food not realizing they were closing in 2 minutes and they made a fresh pizza with the most positive attitude even after they had cleaned. Thank you Vinny’s!

Great Pizza. Quality cheese. Super flavorful. Perfect thin crust. I’ll be going back for more soon.

You can buy by the slice and the pizza is amazing.

Service is great! As far as NYC pizza goes around here, it's okay.

If I could give this restaurant 10 stars I would!!! Being Italian and from Boston and living in Oklahoma, it’s so hard to find good pizza but this was suggested to me and even though I live in Owasso I placed the order online for pickup that was such an easy process and then drove to Broken Arrow for pickup! This brought me back to my childhood and tasted like my very own Nanas home made sauce she used to make us with her homemade gnocchis and raviolis with her boiled eggs in it!! Not going to lie I teared up because we lost her during covid but this is the real deal!!! I will be making the drive every time we order pizza! We tried a few pizzas, the garlic knots, cheese knots and a Stromboli and all were perfection! The crust the sauce, the Italian sausage…. Just incredible! Looking forward to trying a white pie and a margherita next time and their cannolis! If you haven’t tried this~ try it!!!!!!!

We finally made it to Uncle Vinnys NY Pizzeria we ordered a 16in Supreme minus green pepper and black olives add Canadian bacon and saucy. Our second was a 16in Margherita woth extra cheese and we added sausage. We added sausage because we heard the sausage was really REALLY GOOD. So glad we did! The crust is thin as traditional NY style should be and the cornicione (raised crust along the edge) was soft and not tough at all. Definitely fresh dough and not over worked. The sauce was absolutely outstanding and very well seasoned. The slices were cut big and were "foldable" actually... one 16in would of been enough but we wanted to try more than one pizza. We also got canolloli's... did we share with each other...?!?! Fuhgeddaboutit!!! We ate em so fast we didn't even get a picture!!! They were huge!! So super tender and busting with delicious cream.. don't even get me started!! Just perfection! Worth going just for that little sweet treat at less than 4.00!! We got our food to go but they do have inside seating and tons of great staff to help you. It was very friendly and actually what I expected... it was a place you would want to go and have a big pizza with the family and laugh and talk about your day. Next time we will definitely dine at Uncle Vinnys and not at home. They are located in Broken Arrow and have plenty of parking. I will definitely be going back!! Ohhh and lastly.. the prices were definitely family friendly!! Parking: Lots of parking