Thirsty Mermaid

Amazing joint off Duval. The executive chef is also a commercial fisherman. The seafood selections - especially catch of the day - are great/high quality. Respectable wine list too.

The scallops are to die for! Great service. Cute and quiet restaurant among all the noise. We had an excellent dinner. Definitely recommend it to everyone!

La atención buena más no puedo decir lo mismo de la comida, nada especial y encima te quieren imponer un 20% de servicio en la factura, una groceria para la comida y ambiente del restaurante.

Food was Delicious. I love coming here when I’m down in KW. Intimate setting, great menu. They have a nice caviar spread for those special days

It was a first date, it was a lil loud but only in the sense she didnt speak great english. But food and service were amazing

Seared yellow tail was excellent. Crab ravioli was the best according to my wife

We stopped by for happy hour and stayed for dinner. Great wine list and tasty food, but overall, it was not worth the price, nor was it as good as other places we visited while in Key West. The portions were smaller than expected and we left hungry even after 2 appetizers, 2 entrees, and a bottle of wine. Speaking of apps, we ordered the "happy hour" mac and cheese croquette for $8. We received a singular croquette. The normal "appetizer" croquette comes with 2 for $15. It would have been proportionately more affordable and more filling to order the regular size vs the "bargain" happy hour. This irked us and was the icing on the cake for a mediocre dinner experience.

We love this place and have been coming since it opened. We were there twice this week. The yellow snapper was so good we had to have it again. Along with the gnocchi and short ribs. Great fresh local seafood. The raw bar platter is great.