The Sheffield

Great beer selection & food!

Great place to hang out, eat and have a couple brews! Beer list is pretty solid for the area and they do an excellent job filling the hole left by The Tap and Mallet for British pub food.

Went to watch the Manchester United game with my daughter and have lunch. The lady behind the bar was very pleasant and continuously checked to ensure everything was okay. Had the Bangers and Mash, and my daughter had "The Sheffield" Burger. Both were served hot and tasted very good. Nice pleasant atmosphere to watch the game. Unfortunately Manchester United lost, but time spent with my daughter was priceless. Thank you.

Service and location were fine. Unfortunately we did not enjoy the food and regretted coming here (we had heard from a friend it was decent, same folks as Tap and Mallet). They were out of several things (all fried and grilled chicken, except the nuggets). The water I was served had a notable odor and aftertaste. We suspected it was the glass it was served from, my wife's was fine. The aioli we were served was basically white water and was extremely unappetizing. We both ordered the burger. The bun was tasty (from Amazing Grains) but the actual patties were much too small for the bun. They were well cooked but the burger was lacking in flavor. The bacon they served was very dry and almost impossible to chew so we both picked ours off. The fries and cole slaw were good. We didn't order any beer. Overall, for food, there are much better options for pub grub in Rochester.

It's a bit pricey, but overall the food and drinks are fantastic.

An absolute wonderful experience every visit. From service to dining, there is no other restaurant I would recommend more than here at the Sheffield.