Sushi Ya

Food is great and inventive. Always a pleasure to visit.

We arrived at 9:30 on a Monday night, just before the 10 pm closing time, seeking a quick bite. Despite finishing by 10:06 pm, the experience was disappointing. Our order included two rainbow rolls and a specialty roll with mango, and unfortunately, the sushi fell below the standards of even gas station or grocery store sushi. This stands as the worst sushi experience I've had on Long Island – the rolls were poorly made, dry, and tasted horrible. The subpar quality, especially given the price, has led me to decide i will never come back here again. I strongly advise against choosing this place for sushi; opting for grocery store sushi would likely yield a better experience. This establishment doesn't deserve your business.

Awesome food! Super service! Fantastic time! Thank you Eric for an amazing dining experience!

It's still amazing! It's a destination stop every time we are in Long Island! I simply cannot rate Sushi Ya Garden City highly enough. We live in Delaware and it is our favorite sushi place because nothing in Delaware measures up. Kelly and Eric the owners are fantastic, and everything they make is devine. The quality and selection of sushi and sashimi is outstanding. The little touches like fresh wasabi (as opposed to the usual little green ball) are excellent. The pineapple fried rice served in a half pineapple shell are to die for. Hibachi is available. Simply in ambiance, service, and quality there is simply no place that is better. Give yourself a treat and spend some time here. Parking: There is a lot behind the restaurant.

We visited here for the first time since moving into town 2 years ago. The food was decent but seemed overpriced. There are other options like Taku (even though it is not known as a sushi restaurant) that has better food and is cheaper. Also, this place charges a "non-cash fee" which is unfortunate.

First time here . We ordered sushi and ramen. We arrived at lunch time , they only offered dinner menu. I had to ask for the lunch menu… The food was decent but the service wasn’t welcoming. I will not return

All very good!