Stuff-A-Bagel Menu

3.5
(250+ Reviews)
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Bacon and Egg Sandwich

      Two eggs, Bacon on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate.
      $11.95
    • Plain Cream Cheese

      $7.95
    • 1/2 Dozen Bagels

      Describe in order notes the number of selected bagels.
      $15.95
    • Buttered Bagel

      $5.75
    • Sausage and Egg Sandwich

      Two eggs, Sausage Patty on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate.
      $12.50
    • Coffee

      $3.95
    • Nesquik Milk 14 oz.

      Chocolate, Strawberry
      $4.50
    • Homemade Sweet Ice Tea

      $6.99
    • 1 Dozen Bagels

      Describe in order notes the number of selected bagels.
      $26.95
    • 16 oz. Tropicana Orange Juice

      16 oz.
      $4.50
  • Breakfast Sandwiches

    • Bacon and Egg Sandwich

      Two eggs, Bacon on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate.
      $11.95
    • Ham and Cheese Omelette

      Scrambled eggs, with ham and cheese Omelette on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate
      $13.50
    • Cheese Omelette

      Scrambled Eggs and Cheese Omelet on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate
      $9.95
    • Egg Whites and Turkey Sandwich

      Two Egg Whites, Turkey on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate
      $14.95
    • Ham and Egg Sandwich

      Two eggs, and Ham on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate
      $11.95
    • Hungry Man on a roll or bagel

      Three eggs, ham, bacon, sausage, and cheese on a bagel or roll.
      $16.95
    • Jumbo Egg Sandwich

      Two eggs on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate
      $8.95
    • Potato and Egg Sandwich

      Homefried Potatoes and Two Eggs on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate.
      $12.95
    • Sausage and Egg Sandwich

      Two eggs, Sausage Patty on your choice of Bagel/Roll/Bread/Plate.
      $12.50
    • Western Omelette

      Scrambled eggs with ham, green, and red peppers, onions and cheese
      $14.95
  • On a Bagel

    • Buttered Bagel

      $5.75
    • Mixed Cream Cheese

      Olive, strawberry, bacon and cheddar, vegetable, scallion cinnamon raisin, walnut, chocolate chip, vegetable, and scallion.
      $8.95
    • Plain Cream Cheese

      $7.95
    • Buttered Roll

      $5.75
    • Cream Cheese and Jelly

      $7.95
    • Lox Cream Cheese

      $14.95
    • Nova Lox and Cream Cheese

      $19.95
  • Cream Cheese

    • 1 lb. Mixed Cream Cheese

      Olive strawberry bacon and cheddar vegetable scallion cinnamon raisin walnut chocolate chip vegetable and scallion.
      $18.95
    • 1/2 lb. Mixed Cream Cheese

      $10.95
    • 1/4 lb. Mixed Cream Cheese

      $5.95
    • 1/2 lb. Plain Cream Cheese

      $9.95
    • 1/4 lb. Plain Cream Cheese

      $5.95
    • 1 lb. Plain Cream Cheese

      $17.95
  • Butter

    • 1/2 lb. Butter

      $9.95
    • 1/4 lb. Butter

      $5.95
    • 1 lb. Butter

      $18.95
  • 1 Dozen Bagels

    • 1 Dozen Bagels

      Describe in order notes the number of selected bagels.
      $26.95
  • 1/2 Dozen Bagels

    • 1/2 Dozen Bagels

      Describe in order notes the number of selected bagels.
      $15.95
  • Beverages

    • Coffee

      $3.95
    • Nesquik Milk 14 oz.

      Chocolate, Strawberry
      $4.50
    • Tea

      $3.95
    • 16 oz. Tropicana Orange Juice

      16 oz.
      $4.50
    • 20oz Bottle Soda

      Coke, Diet Coke, Ginger
      $4.95
    • Homemade Sweet Ice Tea

      $6.99
    • Ice Coffee

      $6.99
    • Snapple

      Ice tea, Diet Ice tea, Half & Half, Peach, Diet Peach
      $4.50

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Seabreeze Cafe
Seabreeze Cafe
4.2
(106 Reviews)
Bar
Babylon Fish & Clam Restaurant
Babylon Fish & Clam Restaurant
4.1
(443 Reviews)
Seafood, American, Bar
The Delica Sea
The Delica Sea
4.7
(66 Reviews)
Deli
Tres Palms
Tres Palms
4.1
(900 Reviews)
New American, Bar, Seafood
Burger King
Burger King
3.9
(524 Reviews)
Breakfast, Family
VERN Restaurant and Bar
VERN Restaurant and Bar
4.4
(125 Reviews)
Seafood
seagull restaurant
seagull restaurant
4.2
(469 Reviews)
Seafood, Bar, Brunch
South Swell
South Swell
4.5
(23 Reviews)
Restaurant
88 Burger
88 Burger
4.1
(167 Reviews)
American

(631) 661-7646

425 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms