Spilt Milk

This is a bakery worth making a trip to! I’m unsure of some of these bad reviews when really they just seem to complain about normal small business models? They don’t take cash? Great I never have any anyways. Prices are higher than what you expected? Probably because they use very high quality ingredients and everything is made from scratch- not to mention they have staff to support and pay a fair waige to! This place does so much for their community and it’s amazing to see their business grow. The pies are hands down some of the best I’ve ever had. The cookies are enormous, chewy, but soft in the middle. The coffee is fresh, the savory options are endless for quick lunches. Truly a gem of a place and I can’t wait to visit again!

Ordered the breakfast Sammy, 2 cookies (rainbow sprinkles and M&M) and sadly all 3 have no flavor, and 1 cookie was rock hard. Gave this place another shot and disappointed yet again.

Good but expensive. Unfortunately, $18.00 for 2 slices of pie. I found the same quality and flavor available at another bakery in Oak Park at a lower price.

My family and I came to get some quiche and hand pies at 1:10. They informed us and the three other families in line ahead of us who tried to order, that within 1 hour of closing they won't heat any food or serve anything on plates. This was incredibly disappointing as this ruled out our entire purpose of making the trip. If they really wanted to be closed at 1 instead of 2 they should just do so and not confuse customers and waste their time. We ended up leaving and going to a different bakery that was actually fully open for their advertised hours.

Incredibly kind staff and excellent matcha!

Food is good but service is meh. Staff had a bad attitude and one woman was on her phone. I felt like a nuisance rather than a patron at a restaurant. Also, they don’t cut pies until noon apparently?

Accepted tips cash but not payments no manual charge from debit card or credit card/no swipes either/ limited customer

Amazing coffee, delectable pastries, wonderful baristas. Everything about this place is fabulous. You need to go here to experience it.