Show Me Pizza

One of the best pizza places in Austin.

Show me Pizza Went to Show Me on a Friday night. The service was very quick for arriving around 7:15pm (busy time). I was with a friend and we ordered a cheese bread, meatball, and cashville hot pizza. Every item came out at once, which isn’t the best thing when having several courses. This can be worked on! The cheese bread, in full honesty, was really not good. It had a béchamel sauce that was not good in taste or flavor. The quantity of this sauce was so large that each bite only tasted of this. I wouldn’t recommend. The meatballs were amazing! Thick and moist, the sauce was amazing in flavor too. Loved these so much! The Cashville pizza was good! It was spicy, and the sauce on it was tasty and unique. Loved this, but I do have a couple critiques. The pizza was super greasy. Dripping in grease and lots of grease was sitting on the tray too. Another critique was that the pizza was cut into four slices (fourths) , and when you tried to pick up the slices - all the toppings slide off because the crust is very soft and floppy. I probably won’t be back, but the cashville pizza and meatballs were good in flavor! Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly!

Newly huge Show Me fan. We had a group and everyone got a pizza they love - even the vegan. Perfect sized individual pizzas. Excellent live music. Outdoor seating. We will be back.

Initial Take: The place is cool, and the staff are amazing, but honestly, I really didn't enjoy my food. For almost $50 with tip, I got a 12" margherita pizza, a cheesy bread, and a bottle of soda from them the other day, and was incredibly disappointed. Idk what it was, but the pizza and bread tasted like burned oil, and both of them were undercooked and still doughy. My tastebuds might still be off, as I recently have been going through chemotherapy, but there is no excuse to serve raw dough to anyone, and the taste of the burned oil was so overpowering that I couldn't enjoy the pizza. Again, maybe my palette was just super sensitive, but I was so excited to have something tasty after all of my health stuff and was just incredibly disappointed with the results. I might give them another chance to earn back the other two stars in the future, especially since the staff and the general vibes of the place are great. But they really need to up their quality control. There isn't an excuse of it being busy at the time either, since I came in right after 11am and was the only customer in the place, since I'm immunocompromised right now and can't be in crowded places. Edit: The owner was incredibly nice and reached out to me. I was able to try the pizza there again with more time to let my tastebuds recover from the chemo. Idk if it was just my tastebuds last time or if the pizza was really just not made that well, but the second time was much better! These guys have absolutely incredible customer service and go above and beyond to make sure everyone has a good experience. I truly can't give them enough credit in that department.

Could not recommend more highly. This town needs more restaurants that are all about the food instead of overcharging for mediocrity. The Show Me staff does exactly that! I’m not a huge pizza person, but they’re converting me really fast.

omg y'all when I say this is now my favorite pizza place it's an understatement I'm obsessed and I need to try every single pizza before I leave Austin and the only reason it's not happening is cause i don't have the time I will be back. go here. go here and eat the pizza you will not regret it your life will be changed and like me you will try to figure out how to move closer to this incredible gem

The pizza is ready so fast and is so yummy. The owner is super sweet. I’m celiac and have never gotten sick from the gluten free. BYOB.

Cool place with great tasting pizza

We ❤️ Show Me pizza show much! Take out or dine in you will be greeted by one of the most personable restauranteurs in the biz. He loves what he does and it shows. The pizza is outstanding and the no frills easy-going atmosphere and staff is so welcoming. What more could you ask for? (Heart shaped pizza for Valentine’s Day, that’s what! And they have that too! )

We’re constantly ordering from Show Me Pizza on Uber Eats and doing pick up. Today on National Pizza Day I order meatballs with pizza, and unfortunately, they forget to give the driver the meatballs with the pizza. Guess what? They called me right away to apologize and the owner personally drove to our house (15 min away) and delivered a fresh order of meatballs. If this isn’t high level customer service, I don’t know what is. Not only is their customer service top notch, but as a pizza snob, Show Me Pizza is easily the top 3 best pizza in Austin! I hope everyone shows them love and continues to support this pizza spot, because they honestly deserve it!