Shinnecock Lobster Factory Menu

4.3

(425+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Lobster Rolls Lobster Salad Seafood Soups Burgers Sides Pasta Dinner Kids Menu Tea Soda Water San Pellegrino Food Truck Race Food Truck - Gas Station (Highway)

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Regular Fries
  Crispy golden fries, salted to perfection.
  $5.20
- Hamptons Lobster Roll (Whale)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $40.56
- Hamptons Lobster Roll (Shark)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $36.40
- Classic Lobster Roll (Shark)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $36.40
- Classic Lobster Roll (Whale)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $40.56
- Mexi Corn
  Grilled corn on the cob topped with creamy sauce, chili powder, and a sprinkle of cheese.
  $5.20
- Lobster Mac & Cheese
  Our famous chef’s lobster mac has fresh poached lobster with 4 cheese blend + elbow pasta / toasted penko crust
  $22.88
- Lobster Fritters
  (6) Tempura battered fried lobster bites / side of chipotle aioli dipping sauce
  $20.80
- Local Sweet Corn
  $4.16
- Kids Chicken Fingers
  Breaded chicken tenders, typically accompanied by a dipping sauce.
  $14.56
Lobster Rolls
- BLT Lobster Roll (Guppy)
  Fresh poached lobster Classic style tossed with bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $32.24
- BLT Lobster Roll (Shark)
  Fresh poached lobster Classic style tossed with bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $36.40
- BLT Lobster Roll (Whale)
  Fresh poached lobster Classic style tossed with bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $40.56
- BLT Roll (No Lobster)
  Crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, and tomato on a toasted roll, typically without lobster or seafood ingredients.
  $12.48
- Cajun Lobster Roll (Guppy)
  Fresh poached lobster with warm sauteed peppers and spicy mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $32.24
- Cajun Lobster Roll (Shark)
  Fresh poached lobster with warm sauteed peppers and spicy mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $36.40
- Cajun Lobster Roll (Whale)
  Fresh poached lobster with warm sauteed peppers and spicy mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $40.56
- Classic Lobster Roll (Guppy)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $32.24
- Classic Lobster Roll (Shark)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $36.40
- Classic Lobster Roll (Whale)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $40.56
- Diavolo Lobster Roll (Guppy)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and peperoncino on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $32.24
- Diavolo Lobster Roll (Shark)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and peperoncino on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $36.40
- Diavolo Lobster Roll (Whale)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and peperoncino on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $40.56
- Hamptons Lobster Roll (Guppy)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $32.24
- Hamptons Lobster Roll (Shark)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $36.40
- Hamptons Lobster Roll (Whale)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $40.56
- Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Guppy)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $32.24
- Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Shark)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $36.40
- Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Whale)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $40.56
Lobster Salad
- Lobster Salad (Guppy)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with house greens + corn + cucumbers + tomatoes/ citrus vinaigrette
  $32.24
- Lobster Salad (Shark)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with house greens + corn + cucumbers + tomatoes/ citrus vinaigrette
  $36.40
- Lobster Salad (Whale)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with house greens + corn + cucumbers + tomatoes/ citrus vinaigrette
  $40.56
Seafood
- Fried Fish Platter
  Battered and fried fish, typically accompanied by tartar sauce and a mix of fried seafood items such as shrimp and calamari.
  $18.72
- Lobster Fritters
  (6) Tempura battered fried lobster bites / side of chipotle aioli dipping sauce
  $20.80
- Lobster Melt
  Fresh poached Lobster meat with slaw, sauce and cheese / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $26.00
- Lobster Tacos
  Fresh poached Lobster tossed with warm marinated mixed peppers on two grilled tortillas with arugula, guacamole and tomatoes
  $26.00
Soups
- Lobster Bisque
  “The Best” bisque you can find! Fresh poached lobster in broth transformed into deliseaous soup (touch of cream)
  $21.84
Burgers
- Crab Cake Burger
  House-made Jumbo Lump crab cake burger / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $18.72
- Fish Burger
  Crumbed or battered fish fillet served with lettuce, tomato, and tartar sauce on a toasted bun.
  $16.64
- Salmon Burger
  Signature house-made Atlantic Salmon patty Grilled to perfection / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $18.72
- Tuna Burger
  Signature house-made local yellowfin tuna burger (local catch)/ Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $18.72
Sides
- Local Sweet Corn
  $4.16
- Mexi Corn
  Grilled corn on the cob topped with creamy sauce, chili powder, and a sprinkle of cheese.
  $5.20
- Regular Fries
  Crispy golden fries, salted to perfection.
  $5.20
Pasta Dinner
- Lobster Fra Diavolo Pasta
  An unforgettable pasta dish with fresh poached lobster meat tossed with spicy fra diavolo sauce (roasted tomatoes) + spaghetti
  $36.40
- Lobster Mac & Cheese
  Our famous chef’s lobster mac has fresh poached lobster with 4 cheese blend + elbow pasta / toasted penko crust
  $22.88
- Lobster Ravioli
  Decadent + Deliseaous! Fresh poached lobster filling enveloped in thin pasta dough and tossed with a roasted tomato cream sauce (hint of spicy heat) + blended with more lobster meat
  $33.28
- Mac & Cheese (No Lobster)
  Macaroni enveloped in a rich, creamy cheese sauce, typically excluding lobster, creating a classic comfort dish.
  $12.48
Kids Menu
- Kids Chicken Fingers
  Breaded chicken tenders, typically accompanied by a dipping sauce.
  $14.56
- Kids Side of Fries
  A smaller portion of crispy fries, catering specifically to children's preferences.
  $3.12
Tea
- Montauk Diet Sweet Tea
  A lighter version of our classic sweet tea, sweetened with a diet-friendly alternative.
  $4.68
- Montauk Green Tea
  A refreshing blend of green tea, often enjoyed for its delicate flavors and potential health benefits.
  $4.68
- Montauk Half & Half
  A harmonious blend of black and green teas, offering a unique taste experience.
  $4.68
- Montauk Lemon Tea
  A refreshing blend of tea infused with the essence of Montauk lemons, offering a citrusy and invigorating experience.
  $4.68
- Montauk Lemonade
  A refreshing blend of traditional lemonade with a unique twist, inspired by the coastal vibes of Montauk.
  $4.68
- Montauk Mango Green Tea
  Jasmine green tea infused with the essence of ripe mango, offering a refreshing and aromatic beverage experience.
  $4.68
- Montauk Pink Lemonade
  A refreshing blend of traditional lemonade with a hint of cranberry for a subtle pink hue and a slightly tart finish.
  $4.68
- Montauk Raspberry
  Raspberry infused tea, offering a sweet and tangy flavor profile with a refreshing finish.
  $4.68
- Montauk Southern Sweet Tea
  Montauk Southern sweet tea, a refreshing beverage brewed with a hint of sweetness, embodying the essence of Southern hospitality.
  $4.68
- Montauk White Tea
  A delicate and lightly brewed tea, often appreciated for its subtle flavor profile and antioxidant properties.
  $4.68
Soda
- Coke Can
  The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
  $2.08
- Diet Coke
  A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
  $2.08
- Sprite Can
  The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
  $2.08
Water
- Water
  Clear, refreshing bottled water.
  $3.35
San Pellegrino
- San Pellegrino Arancia & Fico D'India
  A sparkling beverage combining the tangy sweetness of orange and the exotic notes of prickly pear for a uniquely refreshing experience.
  $3.12
- San Pellegrino Aranciata Rossa
  Sparkling beverage infused with the essence of ripe oranges, offering a sweet and slightly tart taste.
  $3.12
- San Pellegrino Limonata
  Italian soda, sparkling with a vibrant lemon flavor.
  $3.12
- San Pellegrino Melograno & Arancia
  Sparkling water infused with the essence of pomegranate and orange.
  $3.12
Food Truck Race
- Coke Can
  The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
  $2.08
Food Truck - Gas Station (Highway)
- Classic Lobster Roll (Guppy)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $32.24
- Classic Lobster Roll (Shark)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $36.40
- Classic Lobster Roll (Whale)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $40.56
- Hamptons Lobster Roll (Guppy)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $32.24
- Hamptons Lobster Roll (Shark)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $36.40
- Hamptons Lobster Roll (Whale)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $40.56
- Lobster Bisque
  “The Best” bisque you can find! Fresh poached lobster in broth transformed into deliseaous soup (touch of cream)
  $21.84
- Lobster Fritters
  (6) Tempura battered fried lobster bites / side of chipotle aioli dipping sauce
  $20.80
- Lobster Mac & Cheese
  Our famous chef’s lobster mac has fresh poached lobster with 4 cheese blend + elbow pasta / toasted penko crust
  $22.88
- Mexi Corn
  Grilled corn topped with chipotle mayo, Monterey Jack cheese, and lime.
  $5.20
- Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Guppy)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $32.24
- Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Shark)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $36.40
- Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Whale)
  Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
  $40.56