Screamin Mimi's

We stayed at an air b and b right in the same block (The Present) and by the end of our vacay we were tired and just wanted to hang out and watch basketball. This pizza was AMAZING. We got the white tomato basil pizza and the crust was perfect, just enough cheese, perfect garlic amount. The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming. Would highly recommend as a tourist looking for an easy dinner/lunch.

Phenomenal pizza. Huge serving for the price, but they didn’t sacrifice quality for quantity, as it was amazing. Will definitely be going back

Wow. As a pizza connoisseur, this IS IT! Absolutely spectacular.

We ordered a large pizza for pickup and it was not fully cooked… couldn’t even pick up a piece without it completely falling apart. Kind of baffling. It was very busy so maybe an off night, but not a great experience and wouldn’t come back.

Surprisingly good pizza!! They make it from scratch in house and it is very good. It’s that large diameter thin crust NY-ish style. That was fantastic, and staff was quite nice. It’s also a little out of the “touristy” zone so it was a more authentic “dive” type experience.

Being from New York it’s hard to find pizza I like- Screamin Mimi’s is able to not only fit the bill but make me feel at home. Pizza is great and everyone is friendly