San Matteo Pizza & Espresso Bar

The order never arrived after waiting for 2 hours ! All the time , the tracking showed us that the food was arriving soon. The person who answered the phone said the food would arrive in 10 min but the 10 minutes never ended .

La pizza più buona di New York

Always delicious food and personalised service. A pleasure to eat there at any time. Thank you San Matteo ❤️

The is by far the best pizza place in NYC area. This place has authentic Italian food, you can’t go wrong with this place. As much as we loved the old location, the new one is absolute heaven. I highly recommend our favorite- prosciutto e buffala pizza.

Stopped by to look at the menu. Very pricy. Was wanting some Veal Parmigiano. $65.00 here...no thanks, with a glass of wine close to $100.00. Will pass.

Ordered a mushroom pizza with truffles. Mushrooms were canned and not fresh and there were no truffles. Processed truffle oil. The margherita pizza was good. We let our waitress know that we didn’t like the mushroom pizza after eating one bite and nothing was done about it. She literally threw the entire pizza out when she cleaned our table. No apologies or refund or offer to change it for something else. Not a good experience.