Pizza Heaven

4.3
(234 Reviews)
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo

Ratings of Pizza Heaven

google
Google
4.3
(234 Reviews)

Happy Hours & Specials

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?


Photos

  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo

Location & Hours

357 Old Forge Hill Rd #600
New Windsor, NY 12553
Monday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Tuesday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Wednesday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Friday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Saturday
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Sunday
Closed

Recent Reviews

google
Jan 2024
I can't recommend this place because of how unprofessional and juvenile the employees act especially in front of customers sight. Talking bad about customers while they are there is no class. Also the place is very dirty inside and needs a deep cleaning. Just very icky. Parking is terrible outside, no spots available even though it wasn't busy inside.
google
Dec 2023
Not crazy about pizza sauce but it wa not bad.
google
Dec 2023
Some of the best pizza in town! & they make one of my favorite Caesar salads. The staff is very friendly and attentive. It’s really easy to order off their website and by the time I get there my food is ready to go. Perfect for a Friday night!
google
Dec 2023
It was very very excellent
google
Nov 2023
Pizza Heaven you can do much better! We ordered the office meal deal via the website to be delivered and while the delivery seemed okay our food was cold. We live right around the corner from this establishment so cold food shouldn’t be an issue. The pizza and penne alla vodka were cold, the salad was so drenched in dressing it was unpalatable and we threw it out. You can and should do better!
google
Nov 2023
Great service & great pizza
google
Nov 2023
They have good pizza, especially if you like it well done. For that I gave them 2 stars. It's the service that cost them the other stars. I've been to this restaurant several times and I have seen the following happen or happen to me. Upon paying the bill usually one would hear a "thank you for your business" or just a plain "thank you" or maybe even just a "thanks". But here, you're almost as likely to hear an "you're welcome" instead. I've also experienced, while waiting in line to order, that they help people just entering the restaurant rather than those who are already waiting in line. Sometimes the new people will just shout out their order from the back and they are taken care of first! I believe they know these people. Possibly family or friends I would guess. Yet other times I've been in line and they just stop taking orders and do something else like fold boxes or arrange the food on the counter. I suggest only going here if you have a lot of patience and don't mind this type of service that may be occurring. Update: they have a new employee, maybe a manager type person who over charges. Also gives some people paper plates instead of real plates.
google
Nov 2023
Great pizza and friendly staff. I just wish they weren't handing the food with their bare hands so much. Many people are answering the phone and handling the cash register. Everyone is touching everything with no hand washing. Put on some gloves or use some tongs .
google
Nov 2023
Best pizza in the 845


Nearby Locations

Loading...

Top Cuisines Near Me

Popular Cities


(845) 569-8888

357 Old Forge Hill Rd #600, New Windsor, NY 12553