Checkle
Search
For Businesses
Picky Barista
Menu
Picky Barista Menu
Coffee shop
667 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10025
Suggest Edit
ALL-DAY BREAKFAST
HOMEMADE PASTRIES
ALL-DAY BREAKFAST
ORGANIC AVOCADO TOAST WITH TOMATO, FETA, SPICES
$8.75
EGG AND CHEESE CROISSANT SANDWICH WITH PESTO
$8.25
HAM AND CHEESE SANDWICH ON KAISER ROLL
$5.75
PROSCIUTTO, MOZZARELLA AND PESTO SANDWICH
$8.75
OVERNIGHT OATS WITH ORGANIC CHIA SEEDS, CINNAMON, ALMOND BUTTER, AND HONEY
$7.75
HOMEMADE PASTRIES
APPLE CAKE
Using Mama’s recipe, our apple cake is moist and rich in flavor
$5.50
BALKAN CROISSANT WITH JAM
Bringing a taste of the Balkans to New York, this croissant with jam is so yummy
$3.75
BLUEBERRY CAKE
A variation of our popular apple cake, our blueberry cake has the perfect balance of tart and sweet leaving you satisfied
$5.50
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
Combining this cookie with your coffee is achieving pure bliss
$3.75
CHOCOLATE CHIP MUFFIN
Stacked with chocolate chips, this moist muffin will elevate your taste buds
$3.75
CINNAMON ROLL
Our take on a cinnamon bun, this fluffy roll matches perfectly with any coffee drink
$3.75
HONEY COOKIE
Our Mama’s invention, these little cookies are a perfect one-bite craving-satisfiers
WAFFLE COOKIE
Our Mama’s invention, these little cookies are a perfect one-bite craving-satisfiers
JAM COOKIE
Perfect bite-size delight that pairs so well with any of our coffee drinks. Filled with strawberry jam in the middle and dusted with powdered sugar
$1.50
NUTELLA ROLL
Rolled with Nutella throughout, our roll is soft and tasty
$3.75
VEGAN BANANA-WALNUT MUFFIN
This delicious muffin with bananas and walnuts is sure to please both vegans and non-vegans
$4.25
WALNUT CRANBERRY CHIP COOKIE
Crunchy, cinnamony, chocolatey...this cookie has it all
$3.75
ALMOND CROISSANT
$5.75
BALKAVA
(CONTAINS NUTS) A Balkan staple, our baklava follows Mama’s recipe and is full of nuts and flavor
$2.75
BANANA BREAD
A crowd-pleaser, our banana bread is deliciously satisfying
$4.50
BUTTER CROISSANT
$4.75
CHOCOLATE CROISSANT
$5.50
FETA BUREK
Flaky dough layered with creamy feta and baked until golden
$8.25
GLUTEN-FREE BANANA BREAD
Same recipe as our regular banana bread but without the gluten
$6.00
ORGANIC APPLE CAKE
$5.50
ORGANIC BLUEBERRY CAKE
$5.50
SESAME CHEESE ROLL
$3.75
SPINACH AND CHEESE BUREK
$8.25
VANILLA COOKIE
(CONTAINS WALNUT)
$1.00
Menu Gallery
Menu Gallery
Menus may not be up to date.
Suggest Edit
Know a great happy hour or special for this location?
Add Happy Hour
Nearby Locations
Blossom on Columbus
4.3
(2,628 Reviews)
Coma Bueno
4.2
(115 Reviews)
194 Manhattan Deli
4.5
(97 Reviews)
Garden of Eden Marketplace
3.9
(381 Reviews)
American Wing Cafe
3.0
(377 Reviews)
Homemade Taqueria - Columbus
4.7
(197 Reviews)
Taco Bell
3.9
(861 Reviews)
Mama's Chicken and Pizza
4.0
(53 Reviews)
Baked Cravings
4.7
(210 Reviews)
Top Cuisines Near Me
Restaurants
Bar
Coffee shop
Pizza
Breakfast
American
Cafe
Italian
Bakery
Mexican
Chinese
Sandwich shop
Cocktail bar
Hamburger
Deli
Popular Cities
Chicago
Brooklyn
Austin
Las Vegas
Columbus