Paulie Gee's Short North

It is a classic and authentic Italian pizza restaurant. There were only pizzas, salads, and bar drinks available. The pizza tasted decent coming out from a wood fired oven. The service was fantastic and fast. The pizza was made freshly and quickly, but its price was a little high. The goat cheese was so decent that I could feel the cheese raised the price. Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizzas and salads

The square pizza was phenomenal!!!

Pizza and service is great

Best pizza in Columbus by a long shot.

i have been following this place on instagram for YEARS. i had always wanted to try this place out, because there photos are just amazing they make the food look like it’s the best pizza in the world. me and my friend decided to go one night, after a night out and we came in and got added to waitlist (which we were completely fine with! Because like I mentioned we had been waiting for years to finally have the time to go try this pizza.) We were sitting and waiting and chatting, and than we get seated. We sit for a little but longer as we notice all the waiters go up to the tables surrounding us, and talk to them. But we’re still seated. After a couple minutes they come and ask us what we’d like to drink and we mention our drinks. Then we wait even longer for our food. We’re finish our drinks, while we’re waiting. We begin to order and we find out that they’re out of the pizza that was the ONLY reason we came to this place. And we found that information, not in the 20 minutes of waiting, and not in the other 30 minutes that we were seated AND waiting, but after 50 MINUTES we find out that its out. We’re were honestly so disappointed. It was honestly a very disappointing experience. I wish we could have been notified earlier of this, or even a sign on the door would have been fine. And I completely understand, being tired or anything because I also work in customer service but the waitor we had was just really rude and dry, she would hardly talk to us but we would see her talking away with other tables. And me and my friend are really social, so we love to chat it up especially with new people. It was just a really sucky experience, and the pizza was really small for all that wait, we ate it in under five minutes. I know other people love it but personally I do not recommend.

I went to Paulie Gee’s for the first time tonight but I e been to many other pizza places in Columbus before. I can co directly say this is the best pizza in Columbus. THE CRUST! Its chefs kiss perfect. It has good structure but also gives a little and has good ratio with toppings. Wood fired adds a delightful taste and crisp. One of the people I dined with got a deep dish and I was very impressed with this as well- super crispy cheese on the edges, and well incredible. I’m not sure if I’ll do a deep dish or a traditional next time Because they are both so good. The only criticism I’d say is we ordered the Caesar salad and it really was quite spicy and I didn’t expect it. I wish they had more sides and maybe even a dessert menu but they do pizza extremely well so I’m glad they at least do that and offer a lot of variety in terms of toppings and crust type! I’ve heard to get the true deliciousness you should done in and not take this to go! I’ll be thinking about this pizza for a long time! 3/2/24: weeks came back a second time. Service was excellent but the deep dish was a little over cooked (burnt) on the bottom and was a bit disappointing.

Great pizzas that tasted great and super fresh. Two of the pizzas took a while to get to us, but the waiter comped it for us. She didn't need to do that for us. I will gladly come back.

Sat at the bar and got decent service. Had a salad and a pizza. Paid a premium price, but didn't feel like there was anything premium about either dish. The salad was fresh, but smaller than desired. The pizza may have been great for some, but the crust felt a bit like powdered cardboard to my mouth. I am sure it's just not this reviewer's favorite style. That being said I did eat the whole meal as everything was ok, but not excellent for the price.