Park Avenue Bagels

Ordered a Taylor ham and cheese and a well done sesame seed bagel. I got a Taylor, 2 egg, and cheese on a toasted bagel. My small regular coffee confirmed as milk and 2 sugar, came as a cappuccino. People there are so nice, but I think I must have expected too much being the only person in the store. I accepted the toasted bagel and learned of eggs later. I accepted the cappuccino and they still gave me a small coffee. Just with not enough milk. Way too dark.

Great local bagel spot with friendly and fast service. I got the godfather and added mayo + honey mustard on an everything bagel and it was sooooo good. Paid about $11 for this and it was packed with meat. Definitely not the kind of sandwich you’d find at a regular deli, can’t wait to go back.

Great food and the staff is wonderful!

Nothing disappoints me there. Their Lox Bagel with cream cheese is amazing! The chop cheese is out of the world with the Murphy Burger and. Philly cheesesteak.

It’s honestly hit or miss with the quality of the food. When they intentionally listen to what the customer wants, the food is excellent, but there are times when they don’t take down the order correct. The customer service is really poor, if only they would be more welcoming with everyone that comes through the door, but they seem to treat customers differently. While waiting I wasn’t welcomed, but noticed that “regular” customers seem to receive a welcoming greeting.

Best Bagel and nicest people in town!!

Best shop in NJ