Papa Joe's Italian Eatery

Chicken Parm with Pasta is the best I've ever tasted. Great bread, wonderful salad.

First time eating inside. We used to order from them during pandemic and food delicious then

Some of the best Italian food around for sit down or take out, they do it right. And that's saying a lot since they are in Gates, NY. If you're an Italian restaurant in Gates, you have to be good and you have to be authentic and this place is just that. Throw a dart at the menu and it's gonna be good and it's really great value for your money. They are priced well below their quality. You can't go wrong here!

Been here several times. Great food and service. The chicken parmigiana is delicious and filling.

My son’s wedding of 65 people ran out of food when PAPA Joes said they had enough for 140. The food was good but we were given the run around when we called afterwards to discuss the matter. Very rude management. Excuses were not expected. What’s done is done. We know now Papa joes is not equipped to handle larger gatherings.

Vegetarian options: There are vegetarian pasta dishes here that taste fabulous, especially the vodka tortellini.