Original Frozen Custard

4.1
(539 Reviews)
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo

Ratings of Original Frozen Custard

google
Google
4.2
(470 Reviews)
yelp
Yelp
3.2
(52 Reviews)
tripadvisor
TripAdvisor
4.0
(17 Reviews)

Happy Hours & Specials

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?


Photos

  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo

Location & Hours

Enduring shop, founded in 1932, selling frozen custard, burgers, old-fashioned sodas & shakes.

2319 Wallace Ave
Lafayette, IN 47904
Monday
11:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Tuesday
11:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday
11:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday
11:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday
11:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday
11:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Sunday
12:00 PM - 6:00 PM

Recent Reviews

google
Apr 2024
Who makes shakes with only whip cream? I thought my daughter didn’t have her straw all the way in the cup and maybe just top and getting only the whip cream. I open the lid and stir and it was only whipped cream. I was so surprised. Tried calling to make a complaint and no answer. For the location being the original custard, standards of product have declined. I will avoid this location in the future.
google
Apr 2024
Oh, sweet patrons, lend me thine ears, for a tale of woe do I unfold,. This establishment, purporting to serve the divine concoction known as a "banana split," hath beguiled us with false promises and deceit. Upon yon table, arrived a vessel not of splendor, but of disappointment disguised. A conglomeration of ice, bereft of the promised banana's golden hue, lay there in pitiful array. What mockery, what affront to the noble fruit it bore the name of! No banana graced this mockery of a split, but instead, a mere shadow of its former self. The ice, though plentiful, lacked the creamy richness that doth characterize true indulgence. Alas, the fudge, once promised to flow like the river Styx, was but a trickle, and the whipped cream, a sad imitation of clouds in a tempest-torn sky. Oh, how the taste buds wept, as they beheld this travesty! For a banana split it was not, but a sorrowful concoction, a betrayal of expectations, a pitiful masquerade. Hence, I beseech thee, fair travelers, to heed my lament and steer clear of this den of culinary deceit, lest ye too fall prey to its treacherous charms. By sending a message, you agree to our Terms. Read our Privacy Policy. Don't share sensitive info. Chats may be reviewed and used to train our models. Learn about your choices.
google
Apr 2024
If I could give it zero Stars I would definitely terrible and definitely absolutely overpriced two scoops of small custard shortbread I'm literally 1 teaspoon of strawberries sauce no strawberries over top price was $9 each absolutely ridiculous I should have took a picture of this and not only that the whole cup was disgusting inside and out
google
Mar 2024
First of all, they don’t have menus. There is no menu on their website either. I ordered $19 worth of food, 4 items, I was waiting on chicken, sauce and fries for 10 minutes when there was one customer who came up the entire time I was there, & they only got a drink. I was the only person waiting by the window, an older man who wasn’t even working when I ordered my food held a bag of food out and quickly said a jumble of words of which only “french fries” was audible. He slammed the window damn near before I could even take the bag from his hand. I went back home and realized I have a breaded tenderloin with toppings and fries. I called to let them know of the mistake, I was interrupted right as I said “I was just there a few-“. He made it clear he knew what I was talking about right away, and the first thing he said (after laughing) was “I said tenderloin and you took it anyway.” Uhh? When you shove food out and speak quickly when the person hasn’t even reached the window yet, no one hears “tenderloin”. Second of all, who openly blames a customer like that? Especially when it’s your mistake. You make sure the customer confirms it’s their order, and tell them to have a good one before slamming a window in their face. To add, the toppings whoever added to this tenderloin are the sorriest looking veggies I’ve seen on a sandwich. Overall, I hope ya’ll had a wonderful time making another tenderloin for whoever’s order you messed up and avoid this dump at all cost.
google
Mar 2024
Today, i came here with a few friends. We came here running, when we got here we were walking up and an old grown man, was staring at us like we didn’t belong here(we are colored individuals) . when we got there we were nothing but respectful telling him hi .I got my money and was going to walk up to him, but then he rolls his eyes and puts up the closed sign in front of all my friends. We were baffled. He then continued to get into his car and ride off.
google
Mar 2024
I ran here with a few friends and as we got there this guy was looking at us crazy. Mind you the store hours were still open and there was about an hour and a half till they close. I came up and said hi after he opened his window. We were deciding what we wanted and I kid you not we were deciding for thirty seconds and he said “okay I’m not doing this” then shut the door rudely. I haven’t seen this much disrespect ever. This place SHOULD NOT BE OPEN!!
google
Feb 2024
Who doesn't like custard

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Original Frozen Custard's rating?
Original Frozen Custard is rated an average of 4.1/5 stars across various online platforms.

+1 765-447-2492

2319 Wallace Ave, Lafayette, IN 47904