2352 Sheridan Dr

Tonawanda, NY 14150

This place has truly NYC style pizzas. We ordered supreme deluxe and it was worth the drive from the Williamsville area. The pizza was very thin, with a nice slightly crunchy crust. The sauce was a little tangy and it had the right amount of cheese. Super delicious and the wings were pretty good as well.

I love me some New York Style pizza. These are great slices and just plain good pizza. The chicken and spinach might be my favorite.Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5 …More

Great NY style pizza & kids loved the garlic knots. Panini was on the plain side. The service could improve from the guys at the front counter. Were very robotic lol. Go Bills!

They have the best chicken fingers and fries!

Best nyc style pizza in buffalo ! Everything from. The sauce to the crust . Decent prices def recommend . Literally reminds me of my favorite pizza shop back home in nyc.will return

I grew up on Long Island and I have spent the last 10 years in Buffalo, wandering hopelessly through a seemingly empty and good-pizza-lacking wasteland of unenthused tastebuds coated in sadness. Gino's is pretty good but Olisi's (much more often than not) absolutely kills it. I would highly, highly, highly recommend giving this place a shot. They also make a good Margherita 👍 😌 👌 *Edit: (September 2022) I had a problem with one of my orders. The shop was kind enough to listen to my issue and make it right.

Great location and offers traditional NY PizzaRecommended dishes Pizza with Mushrooms, New York Pizza, Garlic Knots …More

Great food, friendly environment. If you want some ny style pizza, this is the place to go. Also, the chicken fingers sub is amazing.

There is no better pizza in Buffalo

Suggest changes or claim your business