Olde World Bagel

Great bagel spot! They do all sorts of bagels and lots of additional ingredients so you can customize everything to your liking. We loved that they have sprouts! Prices were decent, but ultimately, probably not a spot you’re going to tell people is a “must-go.”

Olde World Bagel was our longest running favorite spot for a quick and tasty breakfast or lunch. However as of recently the quality has really dropped off. The last two times we’ve visited they’ve left off items that we’ve paid extra for i.e cream cheese, sprouts or left on mayo that we’ve asked to be removed. The lettuce is consistently old/wilted, avocado spread is brown… not what we’ve been used to. We really miss the old Olde World Bagel!

Great spot for a breakfast bagel sandwich!

UPDATED: 18 February 2024 tried Old World Bagel this Sunday with a friend. It’s good to see the staff have increased the speed at taking orders, and getting them out to the customers. ▫️08 July 2023 arrived at 0938 waited in line until 10:02 to place my order for a single toasted bagel with cream cheese. My order was ready at 10:31. There were about 7-9 people in front of me in line and it took almost 1 hour just to place an order and receive it. That’s wild. I love this place but I cannot stand the stagnant customer service. UNDER NEW OWNERSHIP SINCE FEBRUARY 2022. I have to deduct from 5 to 3 stars as the new ownership and staff are VERY slow. I often come here now and if there’s even 5 people in line, I will turn around and leave as it just takes too long. I’ve waited over 30 minutes on several occasions now for one single toasted bagel with cream cheese, no coffee or anything special and that’s after waiting in line. Thats an issue to me, it should not take your staff that long to serve customers. Your staff needs to be retrained or to put some pep back in their step, otherwise I promise you won’t see us weekly. Original Review: My service dog and I have been supporting Olde World bagel since 2015. I like the shop a lot and love the bagels. The location of this store it is in a nice shopping plaza, so you can get errands done before or after which is always nice. The inside of the store is pretty big so it can accommodate a lot of people at any time. It also has a nice area to view the bakers making bagels (if their making bagels of course) a nice big couch, coffee bar and a fireplace. So once you get in you can feel very at home and comfortable and the view of the mountains is spectacular. I would like to see this place stay open for a long time, so I will continue to support them.

Bagels seem more bread like then east coast bagels. Disappointed they did not have an Asiago bagel on there menu only cheddar cheese.

Stopped here for a bagel sandwich while waiting for an airport shuttle to DIA. The menu provided plenty of options and our sandwiches were warm and tasty. First time visiting, but would go back! Parking: Plenty of free parking available!

Bagels are reminiscent of east coast bagels. Delicious and fresh despite being Olde. Best bagel sandwich I’ve eaten in a long time! Can’t even post a picture because my entire family ate theirs too quickly.

Always a great option to pick up a lox bagel