92 E Main St

Smithtown, NY 11787

Good food good service

good food good service Thanks

I love this place been coming here for decades it’s clean the food is always great and fresh The people here are always nice.

A bit empty during lunch time. Burger was ok nothing stellar. The appetizer sampler with baked clams, a crab cake, and shrimp was only ok. I didn’t love the food but they were nice.

Old Street continues to offer delicious food. The Bourbon Street Blackened Chicken and Pasta (blackened or grilled) is amazing! And the pub cheese is yummy.

Really, really liked this place. The staff is super friendly, the ambience is cozy, the bar is awesome, but unfortunately, and infuriatingly, the kitchen is habitually incompetent. Despite multiple issues with the food we kept coming back because everything else about Old Street is great. However, that ended today. No matter how you order your food, anticipate it to be loaded with onions and cooked wrong. Management is always apologetic, but I can only eat my food cold so many times (because invariably I have to wait while the kitchen staff tries to fix their mistakes two or three times; I'm not going to force my wife to watch me eat my food while hers is being redone). In short, if you want to hang out at a good bar with lots of TVs and drink choices, choose Old Street. If you're looking for a good place to eat definitely go elsewhere.

Food arrived ice cold. Got it reheated and it had zero flavor. I could not even eat my meal. Others at my table were less than impressed with their meals also.

Hadn’t gone there in years, decided to go again. It was as good as I remember and had a great dinner. Service was fantastic, food was excellent and the place was clean.

Good food Thanks

Suggest changes or claim your business