OddFellows Ice Cream Co.

Came here on a rainy day, love the butter pecan but the rain seemed to have everyone looking a bit sad. Great ice cream.

They delivered the wrong item twice. They are not the best with delivery.

We got there at 9 and they were closing while the bussiness hours say they close al 10pm...

The woman who served us had a poor attitude. Was not kind and treated us like a disturbance. The sign at the door said “closed” so we asked her if they were open and she looked at me like I’m crazy. After we entered to order she would not explain the flavors and told us to read the cards… this place will not last if they keep this staff. Too bad

A delicious ball of goodness. OddFellows' flavors slap!! Perfect spot to grab a scoop before going for a walk near the Brooklyn Bridge.

A great ice cream spot down by the water. All the flavors we sampled were good. They also had 5 vegan options. Cookie jar was the choice I chose, although they didnt have chocotorta, which is odd since the Domino Park location usually has this flavor. Yes it’s pricey, but this neighborhood is heavy with tourism so it’s expected. I don’t mind if the product is good quality and this ice cream is worth it.

Loved the sonic ice cream!

What a delightful ice cream parlor! The selection is mouthwatering, and the homemade waffle cones are a game-changer. A must-visit for any ice cream lover.