North of Brooklyn Pizzeria

March 13, 2024 update...okay the take-out pizza may occasionally be cancelled, but the absolutely stellar response from head office (presumably) has been lovely! Really appreciated the personal response and explanation. Good pizza is one thing, good people are another. North of Brooklyn has both. (And yes, the service stars went from 1⭐ to 4⭐⭐⭐⭐ thanks to K*****'s response.... Happy to boost it to 5 the next time unsuccessfully get a takeout pizza!) March 8, 2024 update...cancel culture at the Geary Avenue North of Brooklyn strikes again. Sigh. Order accepted. Order confirmed. Order cancelled. I was foolish to try again on a Friday. 2023 - Have gone here for years (Covid excepted) & done takeout pizza. Lovely atmosphere and aside from a long wait for food it's solid. But don't bother with takeout! They'll charge your credit card and then send an email cancelling your order! Has happened 3x recently. Last time we didn't see the email - because who constantly checks email on a Friday night?! I waited 25minutes in line only to be told it was probably cancelled because they couldn't get it done on time!! Other than that suggestion the staff wad obviously overwhelmed and not in a position to care about my cancelled order. VERY irritating that they've still charged us!! Aside from this feeling a bit like a reverse restaurant robbery...how about having systems in place where a) you don't charge a customer until you've provided the product, and b) you have a separate line for pizza pickup so I don't have to wait 25 minutes to be told my order has been cancelled. Eat in. Do NOT takeout. Also need my money back.

Incredible

Repeatedly coming to this place. Staff is very polite, welcoming and accommodating. They read and follow special instructions very well. Keep up the good work.

Great pizza, Great Selection of Craft Beer on tap, Open late Vegetarian options: Truffle Shuffle Pizza is amazing!! My go to pizza

Great time out. Fun and exciting place.

They're definitely one of the best pizza joints in the city. Also at a very reasonable price per slice!