Mulberry Street Bar

I’ve never seen a manager handle a customer complaint with such distaste for her patrons. She admitted that they were out of an ingredient advertised on the menu & served it to us with a substitution. She then told us to let her know if we didn’t like it… when we did so all she asked was if she wanted us to have her “doctor it up at all”… why don’t you just make us a new pizza with the ingredients advertised? She then asked us where we were from & instantly changed her tone when she learned we live in New York. Sad to think of all the tourists this place is probably scamming!

Local who stopped in for drinks, and ended up ordering a pie, was told it was portabella mushrooms called literally “pizzabella” named after Portabella mushrooms, pizza came out with canned mushrooms, was told the market didn’t have portabella so they had to use canned today, that’s fine, I understand being out of an ingredient, I don’t understand not telling your customer about it before hand, the “boss” came to assure us we would like the canned mushrooms, we didn’t, we weren’t offered any discount even after complaining after the first few bites that it was gross canned mushrooms, we also were treated differently when the “boss” found out we were locals a parte la pizza che proclamava di essere fungo Portobello ma in realtà era in scatola, questo posto non è autentico in alcun modo forma o forum Gave an extra star for the whiskey cola drink being a little strong Also I’ll gladly come back, 3 people wrote 3 reviews, get over your self

We flew out from England last year to visit this place and Manhattan and we will be back in April, so much history and nostalgia, food was great and the host made us feel very welcome

Tell them Don the jeweler sent you and they'll set you up real nice

Carlo and our sweet server were the absolute best. Food was perfect, atmosphere was friendly! Will visit next time I come to NYC