Mike's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

Love the pizza here

Delicious ziti with added fried eggplant was fantastic.. been a few yrs since I've ate mikes but it's still popping from the 90s ty

So quaint and family oriented! Excellent pizza! We had the pepperoni and sausage pizza and it was Mmmm good! Service and atmosphere VERY welcoming!

Good Lord! can someone teach this guys how to speak on the phone! TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE RUDE AND DISRESPECTFUL. YOU ARE NOT GIVING THIS FOOD FOR FREE! I’ve been buying pizza and pasta from Mike’s for more than 20 years, but today I had it with their attitude, they are so rude and disrespectful when taking the orders over the phone that isn’t acceptable. Guys you make money from US, THE CLIENTS; so take some classes of customer service and learn how to have some respect.

Best pizza in Florida. Lived in NY and this is right up there.

Food is amazing. Food is ready in the estimated time given.

Consistently great for the 16 years I’ve been going here for.. amazing coffee.. feels like I’m back in Tivoli.. 10/10

For a closer look at our experience here copy and paste the link below to your browser. https://youtu.be/IwCnqKAvcpM?si=Tmnhza-hthLJGCM_ I can't believe I've never given my review for this place. I've been visiting Mike's since he first went on his own. This is true NY pizza. The mozzarella sticks are amazing (except once that due to supply chain issues they went with a different brand but they switched back). To be completely honest that's pretty much all I eat when I go. Other family members go for the lasagna, eggplant and chicken parmigiana, etc and they always have great things to say. The staff is always friendly and the owners greet you like family. I always rave about this place and wondered maybe I like them just because I grew up eating here. I recently went to NY and had pizza and came back and very shortly ate here. The memory was still fresh in my taste buds and trust me, this is NY pizza. People always want to compare Mike's to another pizza place nearby but in my opinion, that other place doesn't come close.