Midnight Ferry Newburgh

The food we ordered, the specialty Booba, was a surprise. However it seemed like they were out of just about every other type of ice cream. Not good for an ice cream place

Never willing to make milkshakes. Went two hours before closing and was turned away and this isn’t the first time. It’s bad enough the milkshake is $10, I can’t even get one half the time. EDIT: Just saw your response, this has happened to me on numerous occasions well before 10pm, sometimes as early as 8pm.

Delicious creative flavors, super easy to ask about allergens and get kind and fast service. Nice walk to the pier on the water right next to the shop.

Great customer service

I’ve been to Midnight Ferry many times and have never been disappointed. Their soft serve flavors are so unique & constantly changing. The sundaes and shakes are delicious. My favorite is Strawberry Fields. Our son’s dog loves the pup cups. The staff couldn’t be nicer. If you’re at the Newburgh waterfront, stop and treat yourself to the best ice cream in the area.

Good stuff, give them a try. Today was chai soft serve, and it was amazing!