Probably the best Mexican food I've ever had just wish they had more comfortable chairs. You will not regret coming here. Highly recommended.
Would rcommend the DIY Quesabirria, Setas con Mole Rojo, and Heirloom Tetela! And get the Chicana cocktail - not too sweet or smoky, with a thick foam! The Aguachile was good but I prefer a milkier leche de tigre. Definitely reserve ahead of time as place is small.
Hard to choose which dish was best - they were all fantastic. Friendly servers and good recommendations. Nicely decorated, good ambience.
Yadira was fantastic. Very knowledgeable on the menu. She was amazing. Give her a raise.
Birria was our favorite of the dishes we tried! The hand made tortillas were delicious too
We love Mi Tocaya. My daughter lives in Logan Square, so anytime we visit, we always make an attempt to get here. I'm actually jealous that my daughter can go here so often. The food is absolutely phenomenal. The staff is exceptional as well as very knowledgeable. I can't recommend it enough. The aquachile changes frequently and is always delicious. We were lucky on our recent visit that the birria was on the menu. The cocktails are also top-notch. It's pretty small, so reservations are a must. Cocktails are wonderful as well. Dietary restrictions: Most of the menu is gluten-free or can be made gluten-free.
Had a wonderful time, great food, fantastic drinks, and good service.
The fact that this restaurant charges for chips and salsa when everything on its menu is around $25 and the waitress suggested 6-8 items for 4 people shows how out of touch the menu writer is for Mi Tocayo. $26 burrito. It’s like a $5 lump of coal. No lump of coal is worth $5, and no steak burrito is worth $26. The butternut squash “elote” was an assault on the word corn and elote. The aquachile was fantastic and the horchata was wonderful. The atmosphere is incredibly vibrant and welcoming. Our waitress was very knowledgeable about the food and gave recommendations on cocktails for the table that went over well! I would recommend somewhere else.