268 Wyckoff Ave

Brooklyn, NY 11237

I ordered a tres leches with strawberries and peaches and it’s the best tres leches I’ve ever had. Guests of my bday party are asking where I got the cake weeks after the event bc they can’t stop thinking about it. Mi Estrella is not kidding when they say they specialize in tres leches cake. They know what they’re doing and they do it well!

Best cake in New York

Delicious, Great Tres Leches Vanilla cake. Wonderful varieties, quality and textures of the cakes are superb especially the individual slice sizes you get for the price they sell them for. I will continue to be a loyal supporter of neighborhood family business like this one. I just hope there quality and quantity remains the same .

Big portion. Cheap. Taste amazing.Cons: far away from where I live.

DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS BUSINESS, THEY ARE EXTREMELY UNPROFESSIONAL AND DONT CARE TO SATISTY CUSTOMERS. I ordered a cake for my mothers birthday, and specified that I wanted stawberry filling, the lady who took my order stated that I had to pay an additional fee, which I did. I specified that I had family members that held nut allergies, so it was imperative that they make sure no nuts were present, which is why I paid an extra fee for a fruit filling. Once we cut the cake, to our dismay, we found that the cake was a walnut filling. This was extremely reckless and I could’ve ended bad. I reached out to the bakery to discuss this and ask for my money back, as they could’ve been held liable for someone having an allergic reaction, but they were unresponsive. For the price I paid, I would’ve expected what I asked for, but this establishment shows no remorse for making customers orders wrong. This cake was supposed to be special as it was my mothers 61st birthday, but they ruined it by giving a cake that I did not order. Looking through other reviews, this seems to be a pattern so I suggest no one order from this place.

(Translated by Google) The best Wyckoff cakes 💙🎂 my family loves it👌🏼!!! 100% recommend!!! (Original) Los mejores pasteles de Wyckoff 💙🎂 mi familia les encanta👌🏼 !!! 100% recomiendo!!!

Got a chocolate cake here, for my son's birthday. It was awesome, the lady wrote Happy Birthday on it. The price was very reasonable. The cake was delicious. I will definitely come back next time I need a cake.

I love this place, The cakes are delicious... The best tres leche cakes in Brooklyn

Suggest changes or claim your business