Mehaffies Pies

This place has the best pies I have ever had. All made by hand. And the prices are reasonable like $10 a pie give or take. They also have individual slices, cheesecakes, and “haffies” these bite sized gems that are tiny pie bites. Yep I’ll have to make a pie run soon!

The ladies at Mehaffiies are truly so wonderful and went above and beyond helping me with my "special" chocolate cream pie order. I can not thank them enough, as they handled the order with as much thoughtfulness and enthusiasm as if they were making it for their own family. Genuinely can not thank them enough!

This was the first time I'd actually been at their store. All the employees were great and very helpful.

O. M. G! THEE very best chocolate cream pie I have ever tasted! Dark yummy chocolate!

A must have . Best pie ever Kid-friendliness: Very nice people

I'm sorry these seem. Like store bought freezer pies. THE PLACE IS VERY STERILE AND I didn't get the FEEL OF a BAKERY.. Not Like you get at "Mother's Pies" In FLORIDA. AND THE price OF a PIE is so high for what you're getting. These are puny, gummy crusts, only a little filling, PIES. Final opinion: Yuck. Don't bother.

They make the best pies and cheesecakes! Staff is always so nice.

Be sure to get card for eventual free pie