McGarrys Menu

4.4

(125+ Reviews)

Starters Wild West Wings Salads Fish & Seafood Carnivore Sandwiches Sides Dessert Extra Sauce or Dressing Beverages Merchandise

Starters
- McGarity's Irish Nachos
  house-made fresh pico de gallo, house-made ranch, fresh jalapeño, cheese on top of sweet potato waffle fries topped with chicken. May upgrade to brisket or both.
  $15.95
- Fried Calamari
  Lightly battered with sea salt and black pepper and fried, served with house-made marinara and lemon wedges.
  $13.95
- Wisconsin Spicy Or Non-Spicy Cheese Curds
  lightly breaded. spicy or mild available. choiceof ranch, cajun ranch or marinara
  $12.95
- Irish Ruben Egg Rolls
  3 house-made egg-rolls stuff ed with corned beef& sauerkraut. served with 1000 island dressingdipping sauce
  $14.95
- Fried Green Tomatoes
  Lightly battered fried green tomatoes
  $12.95
- Qual Medallions
  stuffed with mild jalapeño, wrapped in bacon & drizzled with house bourbon dijon.
  $18.95
Wild West Wings
- WILD WEST WINGS
  Flavors: house-made buffalo, lemon and pepper, sticky Thai, BBQ, bourbon dijon or sauce on the side. Includes celery, carrots. Choice of regular ranch, Cajun ranch or blue cheese. Includes 10 wings.
  $15.00
Salads
- House Salad
  Lettuce, red onion, vine tomato, cucumber, avocado, shaved Parmesan and vinaigrette.
  $12.95
Fish & Seafood
- Guinness Fish, Shrimp & Chips
  Beer battered cod, crispy shrimp, fries, lemon wedges, cocktail and tartar sauce.
  $23.95
- Shrimp Creole & Grits
  USA wild-caught jumbo creole marinated shrimp served on top of cheese grits, fried green tomato.
  $18.95
- Three Real Crab Meat Cakes
  three packed with real crab meat cakes, fried green tomatoes. Served with house-made remoulade. Includes choice of one side.
  $23.95
- Blackened Red Fish
  two grilled & blackened red fish, topped with a house-made garlic shrimp sauce. lemon wedges. Includes choice of two sides.
  $24.95
Carnivore
- McGarity's Shepherd's Pie
  Beef, carrots, onions, corn and peas in brown gravy, topped with mashed potatoes and Parmesan.
  $15.95
- Irish Bangers & Mash
  2 large traditional irish sausages, garlic mashedpotatoes & grilled cabbage
  $17.95
- Corned Beef & Cabbage
  House-prepared corned beef and grilled cabbage served with garlic mashed potatoes.
  $19.95
- Country Fried Steak
  Served with mashed potatoes and gravy. Includes choice of two sides.
  $19.95
- Chicken, Shrimp, Sausage Gumbo
  house-made. chicken, jumbo shrimp & sausage servedwith toasted pistolet baguette
  $19.95
- McGarity's Black Angus Ribeye
  16 oz chef hand-cut ribeye, cooked to the desired temperature. Includes choice of two sides.
  $45.95
Sandwiches
- McGarity's Cheeseburger
  House-made pure beef burger on a brioche bun. Topped with lettuce, tomato and onion, choice of American, provolone, Swiss or blue cheese. Add a fried egg for an additional charge.Includes Steak Fries or Sweet Potatoe Waffle Fries.
  $14.95
- McGarity's Reuben
  tender slices of corned beef, grilled sauerkraut, swiss cheese & drizzled with house-made thousand island dressing on toasted rye bread
  $16.95
- Chicken Salad Sandwich
  chicken salad with cranberries & pecans, lettuce & sliced tomato served inside pistolet baguette. Choice of Steak Fries or Sweet Potato Waffle Fries.
  $12.95
- Farmhouse French Dip
  Short rib, aged provolone, served in a toasted hoagie with au jus served on the side. IIncludes Steak Fries or Sweet Potatoe Waffle Fries.
  $14.95
- Grilled Chicken Wrap
  flour tortilla filled with grilled or fried chicken, lettuce, tomato, avocado & ranch drizzle
  $14.95
Sides
- Garlic Mashed Potatoes
  Creamy mashed potatoes infused with roasted garlic flavor
  $4.95
- Brown Sugar & Butter Braised Carrots
  Tender carrots braised in brown sugar and butter, offering a sweet and savory glaze.
  $5.95
- Bacon Brussels Sprouts
  Brussels sprouts are roasted and paired with crispy bacon, typically tossed together to blend the flavors.
  $8.95
- Asparagus
  Asparagus spears grilled and lightly seasoned with salt and pepper.
  $6.25
- Cheese Grits
  Creamy grits topped with melted cheese, a delightful, southern comfort classic.
  $4.95
- Fresh Green Beans
  Fresh green beans, lightly seasoned and sautéed, offering a crisp and tender side dish.
  $4.95
- Seasoned Fries
  Crispy fries tossed in a savory blend of spices and herbs.
  $4.95
- Sweet Potato Waffle Fries
  Waffle-cut sweet potatoes, deep-fried and lightly seasoned with a blend of spices.
  $3.95
- Side Caesar Salad
  Crisp romaine lettuce, tangy dressing, Parmesan cheese, and crunchy croutons.
  $12.95
- Side House Salad
  Mixed greens with choice of dressing: white balsamic, ranch varieties, blue cheese, honey mustard, thousand island, marinara, remoulade, or no dressing.
  $12.95
Dessert
- Grandma's Carrot Cake
  Grandma's carrot cake typically includes a moist, spiced batter with grated carrots, often complemented by nuts or raisins, and finished with a rich cream cheese frosting.
  $8.95
- ELI'S Brown Cow Cheesecake
  Creamy French silk cheesecake combined with chocolate chip cheesecake.
  $11.95
- Peanut Butter Landslide
  Layers of rich peanut butter and chocolate, typically includes a crunchy base, draped in smooth peanut butter mousse and chocolate ganache.
  $10.95
Extra Sauce or Dressing
- Extra Sauce Or Dressing
  Selection of additional sauces or dressings including white balsamic vinaigrette, ranch, multiple flavored ranch options, honey mustard, thousand island, marinara, and remoulade.
Beverages
- Starbucks Brewed Coffee
  A freshly brewed cup made with Starbucks' signature blend of high-quality beans, offering a rich and aromatic experience.
  $2.75
- 16oz Fountain Coke
  Picture for size presentation only, it's not the actual drink listed.
  $2.75
- 16oz Fountain Cranberry Juice
  Picture for size presentation only, it's not the actual drink listed.
  $3.25
- 16oz Fountain Diet Coke
  Picture for size presentation only, it's not the actual drink listed.
  $2.75
- 16oz Fountain Diet Dr. Pepper
  Picture for size presentation only, it's not the actual drink listed.
  $2.75
- 16oz Fountain Dr Pepper
  Picture for size presentation only, it's not the actual drink listed.
  $2.75
- Bottled Root Beer
  Rich, creamy root beer with a blend of vanilla, licorice, and wintergreen flavors.
  $2.95
- 16oz Fountain Lemonade
  Picture for size presentation only, it's not the actual drink listed.
  $2.75
- 16oz Fountain Orange Juice
  Picture for size presentation only, it's not the actual drink listed.
  $3.25
- 16oz Fountain Sprite
  Picture for size presentation only, it's not the actual drink listed.
  $2.75
- 16oz Fountain Sweet Iced Tea
  Gold Peak. Picture for size presentation only, it's not the actual drink listed.
  $2.95
- 16oz Fountain Unsweetened Iced Tea
  Gold Peak. Picture for size presentation only, it's not the actual drink listed.
  $2.95
Merchandise
- McGarity's 16oz Belgium Beer Glass
  A 16oz Belgian beer glass, ideal for enjoying your favorite ginger beer.
  $14.95
- McGarity's Logo Shot Glass
  Price is for one shot glass glass.
  $9.95
- McGarity's Logo Pint Beer Glass
  Clear pint glass featuring McGarity's Restaurant & Saloon logo, ideal for enjoying your favorite beverages.
  $12.95

Menu Photos

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

McGarrys Menu

Starters

McGarity's Irish Nachos

Fried Calamari

Wisconsin Spicy Or Non-Spicy Cheese Curds

Irish Ruben Egg Rolls

Fried Green Tomatoes

Qual Medallions

Wild West Wings

WILD WEST WINGS

Salads

House Salad

Fish & Seafood

Guinness Fish, Shrimp & Chips

Shrimp Creole & Grits

Three Real Crab Meat Cakes

Blackened Red Fish

Carnivore

McGarity's Shepherd's Pie

Irish Bangers & Mash

Corned Beef & Cabbage

Country Fried Steak

Chicken, Shrimp, Sausage Gumbo

McGarity's Black Angus Ribeye

Sandwiches

McGarity's Cheeseburger

McGarity's Reuben

Chicken Salad Sandwich

Farmhouse French Dip

Grilled Chicken Wrap

Sides

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Brown Sugar & Butter Braised Carrots

Bacon Brussels Sprouts

Asparagus

Cheese Grits

Fresh Green Beans

Seasoned Fries

Sweet Potato Waffle Fries

Side Caesar Salad

Side House Salad

Dessert

Grandma's Carrot Cake

ELI'S Brown Cow Cheesecake

Peanut Butter Landslide

Extra Sauce or Dressing

Extra Sauce Or Dressing

Beverages

Starbucks Brewed Coffee

16oz Fountain Coke

16oz Fountain Cranberry Juice

16oz Fountain Diet Coke

16oz Fountain Diet Dr. Pepper

16oz Fountain Dr Pepper

Bottled Root Beer

16oz Fountain Lemonade

16oz Fountain Orange Juice

16oz Fountain Sprite

16oz Fountain Sweet Iced Tea

16oz Fountain Unsweetened Iced Tea

Merchandise

McGarity's 16oz Belgium Beer Glass

McGarity's Logo Shot Glass

McGarity's Logo Pint Beer Glass

Menu Photos

Menu Photos

People Also Viewed