Magdalena's Pizzeria

Drove 3 hours just to discover that the restaurant was closed at 7:15pm! False advertisement. Disappointed.

So I had to share this post regarding Magdalena’s Pizza. First of all, they should not have such a high star rating. Hence, the low rating from me. Why? Because in addition to the bad reviews already, I was just at a party and TWO different people told me NOT to order from Magdalena’s Pizza. They had similar bad experiences with quality and service (nobody answers the phone). Magdalena’s should know that people DO READ these reviews.

One of the best pies I’ve had in Tampa. Flavor was excellent, crust was great, cheese didn’t fall off at all, very well priced. Glad it’s so close to home! I was born and raised on Jersey pizza and this hit the spot perfectly! Very kind staff, quick service, definitely found my new spot!

First time here ordered pick up for chicken bacon ranch pizza and I have tried many if not all places around Tampa Bay and this place and Madison Avenue pizza in Dunedin are the best in the bay in my opinion!!! Edit: 02/17/24 around 1:pm ordered chicken bacon ranch took about 30 min and pizza was very thin and two burnt slices along with this slice here.. for 24 bucks you guys aren’t cooking with passion anymore not coming back

Got their pizza before and it was very good. This time got Chicken Parmesan pizza. Very little chicken on each slice, not enough red sauce, crust was totally limp. Disappointed.

Usually the pizza is great but the staff working Friday 12/29/2023 around 5 PM totally messed up. There was hardly any sauce or cheese and the crust was way too thin. It was an over priced mess. Usually the pizza is great but obviously something went wrong Friday because is was awful. Hope this is a one off event and you can make this right. There is no phone # to reach anyone, so I was not able to call to talk to someone about our experience.

Best pizza in Tampa

The BEST pizza in Tampa. I've been looking for a place for years and finally found it! Staff are so nice and remember you!

Best pizza in Tampa