Macelleria Italian Steakhouse Pelham

My family and I spent Easter dinner at this restaurant, where the food and the service was phenomenal!!!. A server can make or break your experience and our server Lura was awesome! The owner is hands on and made sure everything was superb! Thank you again and we will be back soon!

Food was excellent. Parking in area is not great.

The food is delicious and the staff is very helpful and friendly.

This charmingly beautiful romantic steakhouse will serve you a delicious dinner that will make you feel like you’re on a special date. The menu includes an amazing selection and delicious desserts that will also make you want more. Staff are welcoming and friendly. The real bonus here is that you can choose delicious food at a reasonable price compared to other restaurants. A great place.

I’ve been here 2x, exactly a year apart and both times the food was absolutely amazing. It took me on a nostalgic taste journey. I really enjoyed everything from the bread, to the (juicy and tasty) ribeye steak, the lamb chops, and cheesecake. Even the diet coke was exceptional. I’ve been to Wolfgangs and Peter Luger’s and they are tourist traps, this place is a legitimate steakhouse, best in NY. Also the service, can’t be beat. Absolutely amazing

Love is in the air this place is definitely a hidden gem . I made a reservation at 830 on a Saturday night . We were running a bit late so I called to inform them and was seated promptly when we arrived . The ambiance is great just enough lighting, light music playing in the back and the decor was simple but nice . The menus are on little iPads which I found nice , the server was a little slow to take our order but we were talking so we didn’t really mind . We both ordered the 12oz ny strip mine was medium his was well done. The sides are separate and big enough for two so we got cream spinach and home fries . As you can see we started attacking before I could take a pic lol the food was delicious! My steak was cooked perfectly . He said his well done was a little too well but that’s to be expected with well done lol . The calamari was fried perfectly but the shrimp cocktail was a little too over done . We both got a lemon drop which was delish as well . For the desert we got was a pistachio gelato paired with dark chocolate I would have never guessed this combo to be so good but it was . Only complaint is as we were eating the lights started to dim and we felt a little rushed to leave as they were approaching closing time so I took one star.. Over all I would definitely return . For a steak house the price point was good as well . There was plenty of street parking even for a Saturday night. Pop in if you’re in the neighborhood and want some good eats . Happy eating ️ Parking: Plenty of meter parking

My husband and I go here for every celebratory occasion. We love that this family owned business always makes us feel welcome. Even during popular occasions like New Year’s Eve, the staff attended to us with much care. We love this place!

11/10, absolutely recommend! Every bite was amazing, the service & atmosphere put to shame every 5-star restaurant I’ve been to. Macelleria has the neighborhood restaurant feel with a michelin star feel. I will be adding this restaurant to my regular rotation!