I almost didnt want to write this review because I want to keep it as a secret as long as possible. But, with their dining room consistently filled and orders for take-out always going, I guess the secret is out. Best pizza, hands down (coming from a New Yorker). Finally had the chance to try their homemade pasta dishes, all were fantastic and generous portions so we have lunch for tomorrow. Garlic knots are perfect, get the 10 piece order. Cheesecake is delicious, dense, and flaky. Family owned, affordable, and I hope they stay around for a long time.
It’s funny how Coloradoans think they know NY pizza. This place has good pizza. The cheese tastes like NYC pizza cheese. The dough is softer along the crust, which is what you get in the Western US. The sauce tastes like NYC sauce, but with more salt in it, which I love. In NYC many people find the sauce in pizzas to be understated. So they add salt on top of the cheese along with things like Parmesan cheese, garlic powder, oregano, and red hot chilly pepper flakes. I would totally just add more salt to the sauce like these guys do. I would rate this pizza above NYC pizza.
Real NY pizza. Reminds me of the mom and pop pizza shops I've been to in NYC. 10/10 will eat here again soon.
Closest to NYC pizza you can get in Colorado
One of my favorite pizza places. T is awesome. Always hot and fresh. Great price and service. Always a good time
Great pie & I grew up back East.
Never been before but definitely will be back! The moment you walk in the door it's a homey atmosphere, we got greeted right away and had our pizza and Mac and cheese wedges within a short time even though they are pretty busy! Everyone is super friendly, the food is to die for delicious and the vibe is amazing here! We got thick crust pizza by the slice and it's so tasty!! Completely recommend this place to everyone!!