Libretto's Pizza

Really weak. This is a buffalo chicken pizza? Zero buffalo sauce. Zero blue cheese. Bland grilled chicken. $30. This is trash - order elsewhere.

Update: After 5 years of eating Libretto's regularly for lunch, I can say that it is still as good as ever! A solid 4 star classic NYC pizza. Definitely the best slice in the neighborhood even better with the lunch special. My "goto" pizza joint in Murray Hill.

Great authentic NYC pizza! The restaurant is cozy and great to grab a bite! It smells so good in there! Cool place!

I usually order a slice or a pie from here or Garlic Pizza, which is located a block away from my house. Today, I was craving a buffalo pizza with a side of pesto or with pesto on top. However, the older gentleman behind the counter was very rude and declined my request, even though I was willing to pay extra. His poor attitude made me decide not to visit that place again. If you're in the area, I recommend going to Garlic Pizza on 34th and 2nd instead. They were willing to fulfill my request and their pizza tastes much better with great service. Never again will I go back to this place.

1- Food 5/5. So far everything we order has been delicious and hot. Made from quality ingredients. 2- Service 5/5. Delivered hot and fresh. I’ve only had delivered Pizza from this restaurant 3- Atmosphere. 4- Reservations 5- Value 5/5. Considering they use very good high quality ingredients it’s a very good value. Will continue ordering from here and look forward to trying the pizza straight out the oven in there restaurant hopefully soon.

best pizza in NYC, the staff was very friendly. I will definitely go back again.

My boss and I decided to check out a potential pizzeria that may serve us a delicious pie. My instincts went for a Sausage and Pepper Slice. When I got back to the lounge, I took a bite of it; it was heavenly delicious. Besides, the place is highly casual, yet organized and clean. The service associate greeted me and gave me a thumbs up for my visit and purchase. I would come back for another bite! Vegetarian options: The classic Cheese Slice saves all the trouble to choose this slice over any others with meat toppings. You can also ask the pizzeria associate to make a slice with your choice of vegetarian toppings.

Had the Italian Hero, margarita(sp?) pizza, and chopped salad. All of it the best I’ve ever had!!