Jimmy Hays Steak House

THE BEST IN LONG ISLAND!!!!!! I’ve been coming here with my family for around 20+ years now! The staff is like family, the food is angelic, the ambiance is perfect! You could not ask for a better steak house! 10000000/10 will come back here until the day I die

Great place. Service is top tier. Food is always delicious. Atmosphere is polished and refined. This place never misses.

Can never go wrong at Jimmy Hays, No matter what steak you choose you cannot go wrong , every steak they make is absolutely amazing . The Gorgonzola bread is by far the best G bread out there. Side dishes are delicious as well, I recommend the sautéed spinach. They have valet parking right when you pull up to the front Door. Staff and service is very professional, this is a high end steak house. 10/10 recommend

Jimmy Hays is of our favorite date night spot!

Wonderful local restaurant with an upscale atmosphere.

Worst hospitality ever!! Bartender kicked my friend and I (2 women) out of their seats at the bar so his two males friends could sit! Told us we couldn’t order dessert and we needed to leave, so they could sit. Jimmy Hayes himself, was equally disappointing because he did nothing about it, even though a concern was made by Chris the Maitre D’ (who was wonderful and empathetic) I’ve been going there for many years… and horrified to have been treated this way!!

Cold steak and worst watered down drinks ever. Witnessed the bartenders acting like misogynist pigs to two beautiful and kind young ladies at the bar kicking them out of their seat for thier male friends. That behavior was disgusting and unacceptable and I will never go back here again. So many other better options!

Worst experience in a fine dining restaurant. Bar tender yelled at us to leave when we ordered apps dinner and drinks because we were still there in 2 hours. But the people across from us were there when we walked in. (men). They were not yelled at to leave that they needed the seats. Then bartender threw our to go bags at us. Just terrible. Considering the vibe of the place. Good for men. Bad for women. Don’t go. Go visit gran paridisio. They love everyone!!!!

Awesome steak and sides.. get the gorgonzola bread!