Islamorada Fish Company

Wonderful fish restaurant. I was pleasantly surprised. The food is super fresh. I had the sesame crusted ahi tuna which was really well prepared. It came with quinoa rice and fresh steamed broccoli. It was excellent. The service was awesome our server was really sweet and attentive.

The waitress was friendly, that's the extent of the positives I have for this place. The food was cold. My kids meal was bad, how does macaroni and cheese get messed up? You could tell it was cooked a few days ago and microwaved. The noodles were dry and orange, no flavor. My salad was alright, it was small for the price though. My husband got the worst of it. We figured fried fish and fries would be a safe bet, it wasn't. The fish was cold and the sweet potato fries were cold. His coffee was also cold. It wasn't near closing time, it should have been peak dinner time but the place was practically empty. That should have tipped us off. Why was the food cold and sitting at 6:30pm? Needless to say, we won't be returning. I'm not one to leave bad reviews, but this place deserves it.

Conveniently located inside Bass Pro Shop, this restaurant is beautiful inside. The large aquarium surrounding the bar is a great sight! Their adult drinks are incredibly good . My husband loved the fish sandwich. My dish of fish and chips was ok. The restaurant is clean as well as the bathrooms. The staff is really nice. Overall a good experience:)

Everything was very good and our server was attentive without being overbearing. Food came out quickly and hot.

Please save your money and don't come here horrible experience and the food is not fresh at all

Absolutely awful; Ordered the Tropical grilled mahi 1. Asparagus overcooked no seasoning 2. Mashed potato were decent but NOT served hot 3. Mahi was overcooked, no flavor at all 4. Salsa was good but very basic, nothing special. $36.56, 1 person no drink. The asparagus was an upgrade from broccoli. Don’t spend your money here. Such a different experience from the store. BPS should be embarrassed of this restaurant partnership.

We ordered fish sandwiches, Mahi Mahi and grouper reuben. Nothing special, tasted fine. The reuben was barely a reuben, I did not taste or see sauerkraut. (We sat near the bar, and the area was dim.) We had drinks. The mango colada was good but not strong. We also ordered calamari. It was fine. Portion is small for $17. Our waitress was attentive. Didn't feel like the pricing is justified for quality (and quantity) of the food. Will we come back? Maybe. Definitely not a place we'll visit regularly.

The service was good but the food was awful. They had no tartar sauce for the fish and chips. What we were given was just like eating mayonnaise. The fish tacos were made with flour tortillas which were soggy and it came with tortillas chip which was more then have my plate. This place use to be really good now its really back. No wonder there was no one there on a Friday. I'll never go back!

Yet another restaurant offering higher prices, smaller portions. Food was good though. ‍♀️