Il Tinello

Classic old Italian joint. Great food and service. I half expected Michael Corleone to come out of the bathroom and shoot the his rival and the dirty cop. IYKYK

I came here for my birthday with my best friend and I haven’t been to this restaurant since I was like 10 years old. The food was amazing and I think the portions were fair. I ordered the Calamari, and Trinette al Pesto. My friend ordered the Integrello Al tre Fungi and Pagalia E Fieno. I got to try all three and all 3 were amazing! My favorite has to be the Pagalia E fieno. The mix of cream with cooked ham and pasta may not sound like the most appetizing combination but it was amazing . The mushrooms in the Integrello were delightful and I don’t even like mushrooms. I will say the Trinette al Pesto was great but it could have had less pesto (regardless still a great choice). We ended our meal with the cream puffs that had home made whipped cream, fudge and strawberries and it was so good! The cream was my favorite part. Overall great experience here, they did not allow your water to even be halfway done and they managed the floor well. It was a full house and we were cared for throughout the whole meal. We spend a total of 3 hours eating here. We did not finish our meals because we were so full so now I have leftovers for today Even the coat check was great! Definitely recommend for a date night or birthday.

Service was EXCELLENT and the prices reasonable for a downtown NYC place. Picture an upscale cruise ship type service for multiple course meal. Even the Caesar Salad was mixed and created from scratch right in front of you. Good place for biz or family night.

I was invited here with a friend for a business lunch and man was I blown away by the quality of Il Tinello. The food was all wonderfully prepared and the staff and service were excellent. I'm happy to have been invited here as this will now be a staple for me. I've heard amazing things about the dinner experience as well, so I'd highly encourage you to try this place out.

Very good service and delishes food. Great location and kind owner..defenetly the place to visit. TOP

Everything is fine and the food is delicious. But the dessert is the same price as the pasta and we paid $27.95, $25.95 and $19 for 3 desserts.. stated as: special dessert while we only had the chocolate cake, some strawberries with one scoop vanilla ice cream and 2 little cannolis… this was too much. My pasta was $28.95.

This place is the absolute best. The highly professional staff takes true care of their clientele. Our waiter recommended that my wife and I split the scampi fra diavolo and veal parmigiana we each wanted, and the result was a singular and memorable dining experience. We very much appreciated our request for a more private table as well.