Il Pomodoro Italian Restaurant

We went there for the first time and it is sub par!! No hostess greeted us. You dont need reservations which says it all. My eggplant Parmesan was tough and chewy which I’ve never encountered. We will not recommend this spot or revisit. If you want good Italian food, this is not the spot sadly! Citrolas a much better choice.

This place is on gladiolus and a street that I need to turn on to get to a friend's house. If I ever choose to dine in here, then I will be able to give an accurate report of my opinion.

10/10 would 100% recommend dining here

We went here on Valentines Day and did not have a reservation. They opened at 1630hrs and were very very accommodating. The food and waitress was absolutely GREAT and very friendly. Certainly will be back.

We loved it!! Our 37th anniversary dinner was fantastic!! The food was amazing. Denise was our server and was very nice. I recommend this restaurant to everyone.

Delicious food and great atmosphre!

This was our first time there and we’re so surprised how wonderful it was, the server, Jessica, was awesome. The chicken parmigiana was so delicious and my husband lasagna was the best. We met Denise and Randy and would recommend that you stop there for dinner. You will not regret it. Oh and the tiramisu was so delicious.

So my wife and I went for the first time. We made reservations. We walk in and no hostess so we stand there waiting. She finally walks by and says she’ll be with us as do other servers. Then another couple comes in behind us. The hostess is now attentive because the other couple must be regulars. She says to them “you have a reservation “ and they don’t so we will get you seated. She never asked if we had a reservation or we would have gladly told her. My wife immediately corrected her and informed her of our reservation. We get seated. Restaurant has only beer and wine no juices or alcohol. The service was good the food mediocre. Ceasar dressing tasted like creamy Italian, meatball appetizer was very dry, my wife’s rigatoni entree had big hunks of cheese on top that probably should have been melted before serving. So many great Italian places in Ft Myers and this was just okay for me,

Delicious