Hildebrandt's

Foods pretty good but the big winner for me about this place is it’s milkshakes, best I’ve ever had.

I love this place! It has an old-timey ice cream shop feel. Probably because it's an old-timey ice cream shop. I've been there more than a few times, and usually order the cheese burger, the BLT, or the turkey club. None of them disappoint! Also, if you visit, check out their ice cream selection which they make in-house. I like the banana. The servers are always polite, and in the maybe 10 visits I've had there, I've never had an issue. Parking can be a challenge as they have no lot, so street parking only. I really love this place, so I highly recommend them.

Love the staff that is working here. Stopped by for ice cream with the my toddler for a treat and they were doing a renovation…. They treated us on the house. Thank you so much we will be back for sure!

I live in Florida, but whenever I go back to Long Island to visit my family- I make sure we stop here! I have loved this place since I was a little kid. Great place.

Good diner great ice cream

My daughter and her girl scout troop had a wonderful experience at Hilderbrandt's! The staff , food and treats were amazing . Definitely coming back for more ! Edit : Came back for more. The Alfredo burger was amazing . The cappuccino chip milk shake was on point ! Kids loved their Mac and cheese , grilled cheese from the kids meal and enjoyed their ice cream as well. Great food and Great service at great prices. Can't be beat. Keep up the great work . Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly. Staff is very accommodating and welcomes children !

I visited this place back in 2022 with my wife and its like stepping back into 50s / 60s. My parents grew up near this place and used to hang out there all the time and so I thought some branded merch might be a fun Christmas gift for them. Their website wasn't set up yet to take online order so I called and they were nice enough to take my order over the phone. One items arrived damaged and when I called them back, they were gracious and apologetic, offering to send another one immediately. Great staff, Great manager and Great restaurant