Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Hersheys Ice Cream Menu

3.9
(75+ Reviews)
$Ice cream shop
Order Online
Call
(631) 422-5200
Order Online

  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.

    • 3 Scoops

      $7.50

    • 2 Scoops

      $6.25

    • Large Soft Serve

      We serve Hershey's twisted peaks creamy soft serve ice cream
      $7.25

    • 1 Scoop

      $5.25

    • Regular shakes

      Regular Classic Milkshakes Any Flavor.
      $7.25

    • Medium Soft Serve

      We serve Hershey's twisted peaks creamy soft serve ice cream
      $6.25

    • Large shakes

      Large Classic Milkshakes Any Flavor.
      $8.25

    • Quart

      $13.25

    • 3 Scoop Sundae

      Two toppings, whipped cream and a cherry.
      $9.00

    • Pint

      $8.50

  • Party Pack

    • Party Pack

      5 Quarts of Ice Cream 1 cup of rainbow sprinkles 1 cup of chocolate sprinkles 1 cup of hot fudge 10 cups 10 cones 20 spoons No substitutions
      $80.00

  • Soda Made With Sugar Cane

    • Soda Flavors

      Root Beer, Lemonade, Orange, Vanilla Cream, Ginger Ale, and Classic Coke.
      $3.25

  • Shakes

    • Regular shakes

      Regular Classic Milkshakes Any Flavor.
      $7.25

    • Large shakes

      Large Classic Milkshakes Any Flavor.
      $8.25

    • Regular Crazy Oreo Shake

      Creamy Cookies & Cream shake topped with a scoop of cookies & cream float, crushed Oreo's, chocolate sprinkles, chocolate drizzle, and whip cream.
      $8.00

    • Large Crazy Oreo Shake

      Creamy Cookies & Cream shake topped with a scoop of cookies & cream float, crushed Oreo's, chocolate sprinkles, chocolate drizzle, and whip cream.
      $9.25

    • Reg, ONLY 8 Healthiest Frozen Yogurt

      ONLY 8 Yogurt! 1. NO FAT, NO CHOLESTEROL 2. CALCIUM FORTIFIED 3. LOW CALORIES, LOW CARBS 4. ALL NATURAL NO PRESERVATIVES 5. SWEETENED WITH FRUCTOSE 6. SAFE FOR MOST DIABETICS AND LACTOSE INTOLERANTS 7. HEALTHY YOGURT CULTURES 8. GREAT TASTE WONT GO TO YOUR WAIST!
      $7.75

    • Large ONLY 8 healthy Frozen Yogurt!

      ONLY 8 Yogurt! 1. NO FAT, NO CHOLESTEROL 2. CALCIUM FORTIFIED 3. LOW CALORIES, LOW CARBS 4. ALL NATURAL NO PRESERVATIVES 5. SWEETENED WITH FRUCTOSE 6. SAFE FOR MOST DIABETICS AND LACTOSE INTOLERANTS 7. HEALTHY YOGURT CULTURES 8. GREAT TASTE WONT GO TO YOUR WAIST!
      $8.75

    • Large Specialty Shake Cookie Cookie Shake!

      Cookie & Cream ice cream and cookie dough ice cream with oreos and cookie dough topped with chocolate Syrup and whipped cream.
      $9.50

    • Large The Moose Shake!

      Original Moosetracks & Chocolate Moosetracks ice cream Choc Chips, Peanut Butter Chips Topped W/Choc Syrup!
      $9.50

    • Large Specialty Mt. MInt Shake

      Mint moosetracks & Minty mint chip ice cream with Nonpareils topped w/choc syrup!
      $9.50

    • Large Crazy Birthday Shake!

      Birthday cake ice cream and crazy vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles. Marshmallow sauce & sprinkles!
      $9.50

    • Large Roarin' Gold & Blue Shake!

      Midnight Caramel river & vanilla Ice cream with kit kats topped with blue yello sprinkles and caramel sauce!
      $9.50

    • Large Peanut Butter Cookie Shake!

      Chocolate PB cup ice cream and cookie cream ice cream with PB chips!
      $9.50

    • Large Coffee Crunch Shake!

      Coffee ice cream & Cappuccino crunch ice Cream with crunchies topped with caramel sauce and choc syrup!
      $9.50

    • Reg. Specialty Cookie Cookie Shake!

      Cookie & Cream ice cream and cookie dough ice cream with oreos and cookie dough topped with chocolate Syrup and whipped cream.
      $9.00

    • Reg. The Moose Shake

      Original Moosetracks & Chocolate Moosetracks ice cream Choc Chips, Peanut Butter Chips Topped W/Choc Syrup!
      $9.00

    • Reg MT. MInt Specialty Shake!

      Mint moosetracks & Minty mint chip ice cream with Nonpareils topped w/choc syrup!
      $9.00

    • Reg, Crazy Birthday Shake!

      Birthday cake ice cream and crazy vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles. Marshmallow sauce & sprinkles!
      $9.00

    • Reg, Roarin' Gold & Blue Shake!

      Midnight Caramel river & vanilla Ice cream with kit kats topped with blue yello sprinkles and caramel sauce!
      $9.00

    • Reg, Peanut Butter Cookie Shake!

      Chocolate PB cup ice cream and cookie cream ice cream with PB chips!
      $9.00

    • Reg, Coffee Crunch Shake!

      Coffee ice cream & Cappuccino crunch ice Cream with crunchies topped with caramel sauce and choc syrup!
      $9.00

  • Dippin' Dots

    • Dippin’ Dots Chocolate

      $5.49

    • Dippin’ Dots Cookies and Cream

      $5.49

    • Dippin’ Dots Cotton Candy

      $5.49

    • Dippin’ Dots Rainbow

      $5.49

    • Dippin’ Dots Birthday Cake

      $5.49

    • Dippin’ Dots Cookie Dough

      $5.49

  • Tornado

    • Tornado Regular

      Vanilla or Chocolate Soft Serve with any toppings you want inside swirled up.
      $9.25

    • Tornado Large

      Vanilla or Chocolate Soft Serve with any toppings you want inside swirled up.
      $8.75

    • Regular Mint Cookie Crumble Tornadoes!

      Creme de Menthe soft serve with oreos and cookie dough topping with whipped cream and crunchies!
      $8.25

    • Regular Summer Paradisa Tornadoes!

      Pina Colada soft serve with pineapple and coconut topping with whipped cream and pineapple pieces!
      $8.25

    • Regular Coffee Daydream Tornadoes!

      Espresso soft serve with coffee syrup and chocolate chips with whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles.
      $8.25

    • Regular Strawberry Blvd Tornadoe!

      Strawberry soft serve with strawberry sauce, strawberries topping with whipped cream and strawberry sauce on top!
      $8.25

    • Regular The Basic Tornado!

      Vanilla soft serve with cookie dough and oreos with whipped cream!
      $8.25

    • Regular Peanut Butter Explosion Tornadoe!

      Peanut Butter soft serve with peanut butter sauce and reeses peanut butter cups topped with whipped cream and peanut butter chips.
      $8.25

    • Regular Chocolate Overkill Tornadoe!

      Chocolate soft serve with nutella, hot fudge and chocolate syrup topped with whipped cream and chocolate chips.
      $8.25

    • Regular Caramel Craziness Tornadoe!

      Caramel soft serve with caramel sauce, peanut butter chips and oreos topped with whipped cream and caramel sauce.
      $8.25

    • Regular Come Taste the Rainbow Tornadoe.

      Vanilla ice cream with lucky charms and snow caps topped with whipped cream and rainbow sprinkles.
      $8.25

    • Regular Fruity Paradise Tornadoe.

      Vanilla ice cream with bananas and strawberries topped with whipped cream and strawberry and banana sauce.
      $8.25

  • Hard Ice Cream Scoops

    • 1 Scoop

      $5.25

    • 2 Scoops

      $6.25

    • 3 Scoops

      $7.50

  • Hand Packed Ice Cream

    • Pint

      $8.50

    • Quart

      $13.25

    • 1.5 Quart

      Pre packaged Ice Cream
      $11.49

  • Old Fashion Egg Creams

    • Regular Vanilla Brooklyn egg creams!

      Milk, Vanilla Syrup w/ seltzer!
      $5.50

    • Large Vanilla Brooklyn egg creams

      Milk, Vanilla Syrup w/ seltzer!
      $6.25

    • Reg Chocolate Brooklyn Egg cReam!

      Milk, Chocolate Syrup w/ seltzer!
      $5.50

    • Large Chocolate Brooklyn Egg Cream!

      Milk, Chocolate Syrup w/ seltzer!
      $6.00

  • Soda Floats

    • Regular soda float

      Scoop of Hershey's Ice Cream atop Bubbly Soda Pop!
      $7.25

    • Large float

      Scoop of Hershey's Ice Cream atop Bubbly Soda Pop!
      $8.25

  • Hard Ice Cream Sundaes

    • 1 Scoop Sundae

      Two toppings, whipped cream and a cherry.
      $6.25

    • 2 Scoop Sundae

      Two toppings, whipped cream and a cherry.
      $7.75

    • 3 Scoop Sundae

      Two toppings, whipped cream and a cherry.
      $9.00

    • 5 Scoop Sundae

      Two toppings, whipped cream and a cherry.
      $11.00

    • Banana Boat

      Any 3 scoops of Ice Cream between a Fresh Split Banana. Choice of 3 toppings, whipped cream, hot fudge, and cherries
      $12.00

  • Soft Serve Vanilla & Choc.

    • Small Soft Serve

      We serve Hershey's twisted peaks creamy soft serve ice cream
      $5.25

    • Medium Soft Serve

      We serve Hershey's twisted peaks creamy soft serve ice cream
      $6.25

    • Large Soft Serve

      We serve Hershey's twisted peaks creamy soft serve ice cream
      $7.25

    • Flying Saucers

      Pack of saucers great to share with friends. Call to see if we have have any other flavors available.
      $12.75

    • waffle bowl

      $1.75

    • Small mini Cake Vanilla & choc

      Add your own personalized message. No more than 3 words
      $10.49

    • Single Vanilla Flying saucer!

      Single Vanilla wafer flying saucer cookie!
      $4.50

    • Single Chocolate Flying Saucer Wafer Cookie!

      Single Chocolate only wafer cookie!
      $4.50

  • Cakes

    • Cakes small round Choc & Vanllia with crunchies

      feeds 8-10ppl special cakes, birthday, congrats,etc
      $21.49

    • Small Heart Cake

      Add your own personalized message. No more than 3 words
      $10.49

    • Large Ice cream Sheet Cake

      Serves 22-26 people. Chocolate & Vanilla flavor ice cream with a layer of chocolate cookie crunch!
      $50.49

  • Frozen Yogurt

    • Only 8 pint

      Only 8 Frozen Yogurt. Dairy free
      $8.75

    • Small Frozen Yogurt Pistachio

      We serve America's healthiest frozen yogurt only 8
      $5.25

    • Medium Frozen Yogurt

      We serve America's healthiest frozen yogurt
      $7.50

    • Large Frozen Yogurt

      We serve America's healthiest frozen yogurt
      $8.50

    • Only 8 Quart

      Only 8 Frozen Yogurt. Dairy Free
      $13.25

  • Cones

    • Wafer Cone

      $1.75

    • Sugar Cone

      $1.75

    • Waffle Cone

      $1.75

  • Acai Bowls

    • Medium Acai Bowls

      Frozen Antioxidant- Rich Acai Berries Blended to Perfection! The bowl is topped with granola, strawberries, blueberries, bananas, and sprinkled coconut.
      $11.75

    • Large Acai Bowl

      Frozen Antioxidant- Rich Acai Berries Blended to Perfection! The bowl is topped with granola, strawberries, blueberries, bananas, and sprinkled coconut.
      $13.75

  • Soda

    • Coke Soda Can

      The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
      $2.75

  • chocolate candy

    • Kit Kat chocolate bar

      $2.75

    • chocolate chip cookie

      Large chocolate chip cookie
      $2.75

    • Hershey chocolate bar

      $2.75

    • M&M chocolate

      $2.75

  • Bubble Tea Flavored Milk Tea

    • Reg Original Milk Tea

      $7.25

    • Reg Taro Milk Tea

      $7.25

    • Regular Macha Green Tea Milk Tea

      $7.25

    • Reg Honeydew Milk Tea

      $7.25

    • Regular Lychee Milk Tea

      $7.25

  • Bubble Tea Fruit Tea

    • Reg Rose Fruit Tea

      $7.25

    • Reg Peach Fruit Tea

      $7.25

    • Regular Passionfruit Fruit Tea

      $7.25

    • Reg Strawberry Fruit Tea

      $7.25

    • Reg Mango Fruit Tea

      $7.25

  • Bubble Tea Smoothie/ Slushy

    • Reg Peach Smoothie/ Slushy

      $7.25

    • Reg Honeydew Smoothie/ Slushy

      $7.25

    • Original Milk Tea Smoothie/ Slushy

      $7.25

    • Reg Strawberry Smoothie/ Slushy

      $7.25

    • Reg Macha Green Tea Smoothie/ Slushy

      $7.25

    • Reg Taro Smoothie/ Slushy

      $7.25

    • Reg Passionfruit Smoothie/ Slushy

      $7.25

    • Reg Lychee Smoothie/ Slushy

      $7.25

    • Reg Kiwi Smoothie/ Slushy

      $7.25

    • Reg Mango Smoothie/ Slushy

      $7.25

  • Hershey Refreshers

    • Large Size Refresher

      Try our delicious refreshers!
      $6.50

    • Regular Size Refresher

      Try our delicious refreshers!
      $5.50

  • Novelties

    • Ninja Turtle Popsicles

      Tropical punch flavor
      $4.75

    • Dixie Cup Vanilla

      Small 4oz cup vanilla
      $3.25

    • fire cracker Popsicle

      $3.25

    • SpongeBob Popsicle

      $4.75

    • Dixie Cup Chocolate

      4oz form cup!
      $3.25

    • Powerpuff Popsicle

      Cherry flavor with gum ball eyes
      $4.75

    • Sonic Popsicle

      Blue raspberry & cherry flavor with gum ball eyes
      $4.75

    • Minions Popsicle

      $4.75

    • Space jam Popsicle

      Orange & cherry flavor with gum ball eyes
      $4.75

    • Watermelon Rocket Popsicle

      Watermelon & lime flavor
      $4.50

    • Unicorn Wonder Rocket Popsicle

      Pink lemonade, sweet berry, & frosted cupcake flavor
      $4.50

    • Nerds Rocket Popsicle

      Strawberry, watermelon, & grape flavor
      $4.50

    • Kung Fu Panda 4 Popsicle

      Black cherry flavor
      $4.75

    • Miraculous Popsicle

      Green apple flavor
      $4.75

  • Sky High Sundaes Designer High Cups!

    • Large Fudgey Cookie & Cream Sky High!

      Cookie & Cream & Chocolate Ice cream Layered w/ Crushed Oreos & Hot Fudge!
      $10.75

    • Large Sky High Moose on the Loose!

      Original Moosetracks , Mint moose & chocolate moose ice cream layered w/ chocolate chips, crunchies & Hot Fudge!
      $10.75

    • Large West Islip Golden Lion Sky High!

      Midnight Carmel river & Extreme chocolate ice cream layered w/kit kats, crunchies & blue sprinkles & caramel sauce!
      $10.75

    • Large Peanut Butter Bliss Sky High!

      Chocolate PB cups ice cream & cookie cream Ice cream layered w/ MInt PB cups PB chips and PB sauce!
      $10.75

    • Large Coffee Craze Sky high!

      Coffee ice cream< Cappuccino Crunch Ice cream Layered w/ crunchies Chocolate Chips, Hot fudge & Caramel Sauce!
      $10.75

    • Large Cool Arctic Mint Chip Sky High!

      Minty mint Chocolate chip & Mint Moose tracks Ice Cream Layered w/ Nonpareils, Crushed Oreos & Hot Fudge!
      $10.75

    • Large Happy Birthday to You Sky High!

      Birthday cake & Crazy Vanilla Ice Cream Layered W/Rainbow sprinkles M & M marshmallow sauce!
      $10.75

    • Large Chocolate Explosion Sky High!

      Better Brownie Batter, Extreme Chocolate & Chocolate Moose Tracks Ice cream layered W/ Crunched Oreos, Crunched Kit Kats & Hot Fudge!
      $10.75

    • Reg. Fudgey Cookie & Cream Sky high!

      Cookie & Cream & Chocolate Ice cream Layered w/ Crushed Oreos & Hot Fudge!
      $9.75

    • Reg. Moose On Loose Sky high!

      Original Moosetracks , Mint moose & chocolate moose ice cream layered w/ chocolate chips, crunchies & Hot Fudge!
      $9.75

    • Reg. West Islip Golden lion Sky high!

      Midnight Carmel river & Extreme chocolate ice cream layered w/kit kats, crunchies & blue sprinkles & caramel sauce!
      $9.75

    • Reg. Peanut Butter Bliss Sky High!

      Chocolate PB cups ice cream & cookie cream Ice cream layered w/ MInt PB cups PB chips and PB sauce!
      $9.75

    • Reg. Coffee Craze Sky High!

      Coffee ice cream< Cappuccino Crunch Ice cream Layered w/ crunchies Chocolate Chips, Hot fudge & Caramel Sauce!
      $9.75

    • Reg. Cool Arctic Mint Chip Sky High!

      Minty mint Chocolate chip & Mint Moose tracks Ice Cream Layered w/ Nonpareils, Crushed Oreos & Hot Fudge!
      $9.75

    • Reg. Happy Birthday To You Sky High!

      Birthday cake & Crazy Vanilla Ice Cream Layered W/Rainbow sprinkles M & M marshmallow sauce!
      $9.75

    • Reg, Chocolate Explosion Sky High!

      Better Brownie Batter, Extreme Chocolate & Chocolate Moose Tracks Ice cream layered W/ Crunched Oreos, Crunched Kit Kats & Hot Fudge!
      $9.75

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Sugar Island Bake Shop
Sugar Island Bake Shop
5.0
(8 Reviews)
Bakery
Seabreeze Cafe
Seabreeze Cafe
4.2
(106 Reviews)
Bar
Babylon Fish & Clam Restaurant
Babylon Fish & Clam Restaurant
4.1
(443 Reviews)
Seafood, American, Bar
The Delica Sea
The Delica Sea
4.7
(66 Reviews)
Deli
Tres Palms
Tres Palms
4.1
(900 Reviews)
New American, Bar, Seafood
Bagel Factory
Bagel Factory
4.3
(383 Reviews)
Bagel shop
Wendy's
Wendy's
3.8
(582 Reviews)
Hamburger, Restaurant
Burger King
Burger King
3.9
(524 Reviews)
Breakfast, Family
IHOP
IHOP
4.4
(1,081 Reviews)
Breakfast, American, Family
Hong Kong Chinese Food
Hong Kong Chinese Food
3.0
(77 Reviews)
Chinese, Asian, Restaurant
http://hersheysofwestislip.com/
(631) 422-5200

470 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY 11795

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms